Elizabeth Farrelly's No Boys Allowed?

Superior Essays
No Boys Allowed
In a scientific point of view nature causes gender differences in interests/behaviors. But in reality nurturing holds more credibility on gender differences. “Gender is a social construct” means gender is created through society and culture, and this is prescribed as appropriate behavior for a person based on their gender. The view above isn’t uncommon within teacher’s training in college and public schools. This view has a great potential to hurt boys because teachers aren’t allowing boys to be boys. Boys are being punished by their schools for being boys; they’re being taught to have the behavior and preferences of girls.
When boys don’t keep up with the reading, writing and behavior at the same rate as girls, they are usually
…show more content…
Ritalin is drug that affects the central nervous system that helps with ADHD. Describing a case of boys being punished for being hyper, Elizabeth Farrelly, author of Sedation Nation the Cost of Taking Boisterous Out of Boys, describes, “There’s also this: although, in Australia as elsewhere, the male-to-female ADHD ratio is 2.45:1, Ritalin rates are 5:1.”(Farrelly, par.10). ADHD stands for Attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder which makes a person hyperactive and impulsive. 5 males take ritalin compared to 1 female taking it. Which means even if a female is diagnosed with ADHD they’re not as likely to be prescribed ritalin as male would. That would make it so males are more likely to be drugged up, thus increasing the risk of drug addiction. Also if the ratio is 2.45:1, the ritalin rate should also be 2.45:1 that would make the ratios correct. So that means the ratios are biased and gender has to do with an individual taking ritalin. Explaining the prescription rates, Farrelly claims, “Ritalin prescriptions have quadrupled in seven years, which might be explained by the drug being covered by a government subsidy…”(Farrelly, Par.9). Ritalin isn’t a safe drug for children that don’t have ADHD. Side effects such as fast heartbeat and high blood pressure are common severe effects of taking ritalin. But the uncommon side effects are all …show more content…
According to Farrelly, “Thirty years ago Australian primary schools employed five male teachers for every four females. By 2006 there was one male teacher for every four females.”(Farrelly, par.4). The ratio of male to female teachers is becoming more unbalanced. Since there are so many female teachers, the lack of male presence makes boys feel intimidated. Female teachers can teach boys how to behave like girls which results in “gender is a social construct”. Boys aren’t liked by female teachers because they prefer quiet girls sitting listening to them at all times. But boys aren’t born by nature to sit for hours without moving. The lack of male role models also makes boys become more like girls because there’s no male teachers to guide them. Giving an example of lack of male influence, Conlin, proclaims, “Hug a girl, he could be labeled a “toucher” and swiftly suspended-a result of what some say is an interesting anti-boy culture…”(Conlin, pg. 172). Boys are punished severely for something that isn’t even that serious. The lack of male teacher influence means female teachers could punish boys however they want. That affects boys which makes them think that they can’t touch anyone or they’ll get in trouble. This is a result of anti-boy culture created in school by female teachers. A male teacher wouldn’t punish boys as harshly as female

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    Complications Of ADHD

    • 2160 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder otherwise known as ADHD is the most common behavioral disorder in children in the United States affecting about 4.7 million children ages 3-17. The most common treatment children with ADHD is drug therapy, a prescribed stimulant narcotic. The number of children in the United States who are treated with prescription drugs for ADHD has increased significantly. The concern between doctors, parents, and child advocates are that too many children are unnecessarily taking ADHD medications. There are many accounts to understand, one of them being the complications that ADHD drug therapy can cause such as insomnia and irritability, the abuse of the drugs taken by patients and non-patients, and the effects…

    • 2160 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Diagnostic Writing Assignment Tannen has a very interesting point. She states that boys are more susceptible to learn in a more hostile environment such as criticizing and tearing apart the the message that they have read. Girls on the other hand want to talk out what they have read and try to relate to the message. I agree with Tannen and the claims she states about how girls and boys learn in different ways.…

    • 325 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In “Have Today’s Schools failed Male Students?” author Patricia Dalton debate about the subject whether today’s school have failed male students. Standing on a point of psychologist, she has experience of being a mother of two daughters and a son, she was able to give out a lot of evidence about how people neglect the needs of boys. She has shown that for so many years, people tend to distinguish the way to treat boys and girls. People treat boys and girls differently and tend to pay more attention to girls than boys.…

    • 567 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hidden Lessons Analysis

    • 916 Words
    • 4 Pages

    American University professors David and Myra Sadker work together to expose gender bias in the education system. In the excerpt “Hidden Lessons,” from their book Failing at Fairness: How Our Schools Cheat Girls (1994), the Sadkers shed light on social injustices within the education system. They use examples from controlled simulations to show their audience how gender bias happens right before their eyes. Their argument says that there is gender bias in schools, but many teachers, parents, and students aren’t even aware of it.…

    • 916 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Going back to Martin’s work, she suggests how school teachers condition their students to behave in certain ways that reflect their gender. Girls’ behaviour was corrected much sooner than those of boys’. This promotes girls to exhibit well-mannered behaviour, all while delving into feminine activities such as playing dress-up and choosing colours like pink. On the contrary, teachers were more flexible with boys’ misconduct, and encouraged them to participate in activities that involved more action, and choosing colours like blue.…

    • 559 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    He said that he thinks women tend to use more words and are a bit more expressive in their teaching style. On the other hand, he said he thinks that men use less words and more hands on applications to explain ideas when they teach. He expanded saying that he thinks that is changing because they are being taught that no matter who the teacher is, the big difference is the learning styles between boys and girls varies. He finished off his answer stating, “How can the teacher teach to boys and girls while utilizing all teaching strategies?”. This is exactly what we discussed in class, the idea or stereotype that men use less words and are more hands on, while women tend to use more words, expressions, and…

    • 1916 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Effects Of Adhd On Boys

    • 1292 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder, ADHD, is a common disorder that affects an estimated 8 % to 10 % of school age children. (Mary L. Gavin) It may seem that boys are being over diagnosed with ADHD when they really are not. Many girls are diagnosed with ADHD as well, although the symptoms are very different from boys. Children with ADHD act without thinking, are hyperactive, and have trouble focusing. Of course, all children act this way once in a while.…

    • 1292 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If used over a long period, cardiovascular risks may occur. “There also is “abundant evidence” that people who have not been diagnosed with ADHD take the drugs as mood elevators and performance enhancers” (Rasmussen). Students with lower grade point averages, stress, anxiety or depression are those at greater risk for misusing stimulants. Because stimulants increase wakefulness, suppress appetite and increase focus and attention, they are often abused for weight loss or performance improvement, also being used for recreational purposes. Studies show that adults who’ve been prescribed stimulants as children haven’t had any increase in substance use or abuse patterns.…

    • 723 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Girls are expected to be submissive, less aggressive, popular, beautiful, and take on traditional nurturing roles; while boys are expected to be active, dominate, aggressive, and more independent. My school, friends, and community also emphasized appropriate gendered behavior. As mentioned in a previous assignment, I learned from my friends that having stuffed animals was not considered masculine, and when we were having recess at school, I learned the socially acceptable ways for boys to behave. The youth sports I participated in also taught me acceptable gender behavior. They were structured in the same way as the soccer league described by Michael Messner.…

    • 821 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hormones And Gender Essay

    • 1017 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Research has confirmed that hormones play a major role in determining one’s gender. Hormones main function is to deliver messages from glands to cells. These messages ensure the maintenance of chemical levels in the blood system to achieve homeostasis (Gladue, 1994). The Hormones appear and produce the act of a catalyst for the chemical changes that are needed for energy, development, and growth. Steroid hormones are the common hormone related to fertility and sexual maturation of a person (Gladue, 1994).…

    • 1017 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    79). Parental figures teach children how they fit into society and children then act accordingly. Thankfully, meanings are not linear, therefore, they can be changed. To further explain, if a teacher is teaching boys to be strong and girls to be helpful a parent can alter these masculine and feminine meanings. They can let their children know that their teacher views boys as being strong and girls as being helpful, but that does not have to be their children’s idea of what it means to be masculine or feminine.…

    • 1196 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Boys are more likely to influence their male and female peers by using direct requests then girls who try to influence others by using indirect request which are bracketed by polite phrases. Moreover, teachers reinforce the gender roles in the educational system by choosing textbooks and other curriculum that depict traditional gender roles, and present females as invisible and incompetent. In classrooms, girls and boys are treated in a way that promotes control among boys and helplessness among girls. Boys are allowed by teachers to interrupt the lecture while girls are discouraged to do so. Teachers praise female students on their appearance and male students on their academic performance…

    • 1078 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Through the early stages of development and socialization, children have been taught to understand the concept of gender. A recent study conducted by Barbara A. Kerr and Karen D. Milton examined the environmental influences that affect children and distinguish them from their associates of the opposite sex. This included the concepts of masculinity and femininity, which have been portrayed through the social construction of gender norms. Another critical aspect that was explored involved gifted children and the obstacles they have experienced in their academic pursuits. Other findings have exhibited similar distinction between males and females in both positive and negative contexts.…

    • 509 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The media is present around us everywhere we go, may it be in newspapers, advertisements, social networking or magazines. Our mind ingests and registers these images without us having a say in it. Whether we want or not to view these images our subconscious uses them to build our social behavior. Not only do these bias images invade our minds but they also shape the way in which we see the world. Media plays a meaningful role in entertaining, informing, and introducing values to diverse audiences in society.…

    • 772 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Skinnari (2013) indicates that when in a separate class from boys, girls were more active during lessons and even girls who had been quiet during previous lessons with boys present, felt now more comfortable participating. However, single-gender classes also widen the gender-gap, and, as indicated by Frawley (2005), this can lead to two different types of education and to the assumption that boys and girls need separate environments in order to succeed in their studies. This also decreases the amount of interaction girls and boys have with each other, therefore…

    • 1232 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays