Dominant And Subordinate Analysis

Great Essays
Society is presumed to consist of both dominant and subordinate figures who cooperate to establish social norms, yet the imbalance of power between the two entities suggests otherwise. Dominants posses the resources needed to configure the world according to their inclinations, while subordinates do not, contriving the question of who composes the authoritative society that dictates culture and ethics. Dominants are able to use their power to establish social norms, create traditions, and spread ideologies that maintain their power. These ideologies become ingrained into our culture and become further supported by social subordinates. Consequently, these dominant ideologies become an irrefutable aspect of everyday life. Jean Twenge, the author …show more content…
Dominants and subordinates ought to seek to understand one another in order to establish a productive coexistence. An important facet of productive dominant-subordinate relationships is understanding diversity. It is easy to develop a provincial view of the world based on one’s upbringing, however; it is important to discern differences in class, culture, and cultivation. Globalization has left Westerners with the ideal that their processes are not only right but also boundlessly applicable. America, notably, has an issue with generalizing issues by assuming that what applies to one category of people will automatically apply to another, and with self-declaring themselves a dominant nation. According to American society, everyone needs antidepressant medication, everyone needs love, and everyone needs high self-esteem. These self righteous dispositions serves as a blockade to understanding what is truly valued in other civilizations. While American depression is believed to be treatable with medication, the Japanese experience of depression, utsubyô, is described as a rare diseases that impairs one’s ability to live a normal life, and cannot be treated with medication (Watters 516). Experiencing sadness is even commemorated in Japan since it makes someone appear more aware and empathetic. In fact, “Feelings of overwhelming sadness were often venerated in television shows, movies, and popular songs,” while in American culture, feelings of unbearable sadness warrant mental illness diagnoses, and are not venerated (Watters 522). Although they understood that differing cultural perspectives were holding up sales, GlaxoSmithKline persisted with marketing depression in Japan. Instead of respecting the Japanese culture, they decided to infect Japanese society

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    In society, more often than not, individuals are expected to uphold a certain appearance and image of themselves; men are supposed to act masculine, while women are pressured to act in a feminine manner. These expectations extend to social class systems as well; the rich and upper middle class families are always expected to accomplish greatness, while lower class families are not believed to achieve anything of value in their lifetime. If these societal values are challenged, the offender will be outcasted from society. Which eventually causes individuals to give up on identity formation and conform to societal expectations. Similarly, Karen Ho and Susan Faludi, authors of “Biographies of Hegemony” and “The Naked Citadel”, discuss the formation…

    • 2458 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Do I perceive the same exact color red as you do? If not, does that mean color is impossible to standardize? These abstractions help paint the complexity of the human state of mind, or rather, our understanding of it. Ethan Watter’s “The Mega Marketing of Depression in Japan” narrates how western medicine and perceptions of depression encroached into the Japanese culture, and in particular, how pharmaceutical companies attempt to generalize this phenomenon despite cultural differences. Elephants and humans share even larger structural differences in Charles Siebert’s “An Elephant Crackup,” yet, elephants are taught to heal from trauma the same way humans do.…

    • 1320 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout today’s modern culture or even societies from the past, numerous groups or communities have played an immense role in creating a world that is more intelligible, responsive, and aware of differing people’s beliefs and values through the categorization of cultural identities. Furthermore, Nealon and Searls Giroux in “The Theory Toolbox” assert the importance of cultural subjects providing a more interconnected and communicative society, but also stressed the false notions of generalizations on an individual basis, whether through identity categories or preconceived judgments. In fact, as a biracial American, this narrative of battling common myths or ideologies dealing with subject positions derived from culture has applied to my…

    • 1186 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A Dangerous Desire to Be Conventional “If they give you ruled paper, write the other way. ”- Juan Ramón Jiménez. Ray Bradbury uses this quote in his novel Fahrenheit 451 to highlight a central theme that reoccurs throughout Fahrenheit; the importance of individuality and nonconformity.…

    • 1173 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Soon after the pharmaceutical companies started advertising with television that depression was “a cold for the soul” or “kokoro no kaze” (Watters 519). This proves that the systematic does have influence, because their sales went up, proving that they were successful. The pharmaceutical companies were able “to influence, at the most fundamental level, the Japanese understanding of sadness and depression” (Watters 516). The systematic effect of the company worked to get people to reconsider their understanding of depression. The pharmaceutical companies were successful in altering mindsets and thereby the individual choice was limited due to the increased awareness of depression.…

    • 1413 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Since its beginning, mankind has been engaged in a desperate struggle for power. In attempts to secure this power, many leaders and groups worked toward forming empires and societies. While few ultimately accomplished this to any degree of significance, some of these endeavors resulted in the paragons of today’s most accomplished organizations. While a number of similarities likely accounted for the overall prosperity, it can be argued that successful communities have always shared a specific common factor: an established set of social norms or rules to create a unified cohesion among its citizens. Though these expectations or obligations inevitably varied, they nevertheless existed and underpinned the fragile nature of society.…

    • 1158 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    In her essay “Illness as Metaphor” Susan Sontag, an American writer, argues that metaphors surrounding illnesses like cancer or tuberculosis (TB) only serve to increase patient suffering by muddling the real meaning of having an illness with fantasies to cover up what is thought to be an undesirable attribute in a group of people. Similarly men at The Citadel use metaphors to change how women are viewed to ensure that they are seen as a threat that needs to be kept distant so that undesired feminine qualities do not enter the institution. In the essay “The Mega Marketing of Depression in Japan” by Ethan Watters, an American journalist, details the efforts of the Western drug company GlaxoSmithKline made in order to introduce new understandings of depression and sadness in order to enter the SSRI market in Japan. Japanese psychiatry and popular belief only acknowledged depression as a rare illness that can easily be…

    • 1782 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As humans, we often assume that our sole purpose in life is to be happy at all times. Consequently narratives such as our physiological system, experience and culture systems on have taken advantage of this assumption and marketed happiness to vulnerable people who desire to attain happiness. In the article, “Immune to Reality” by Daniel Gilbert, the author discusses with the readers how our psychological system markets positive thoughts during negative situations in order to make us happy. Also, Evan Watters, the author of “The Mega-Marketing of Depression in Japan” explores how pharmaceutical companies market happiness through the sale of pills in Japan.…

    • 971 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Organic Food Depression

    • 1586 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In short, they were learning how to market a disease” (Watters 516). When pharmacy companies make products, they do not simply attempt to make a product that will help with diseases, because if they were to do that, they may possibly only be able to market that product to a small group of people. In an effort to mass market their products, big pharmacy corporations attempt to gain insight into how cultures shape the illness experience and manipulate that. For instance, in an attempt to make sure their new antidepressant pill Paxil could reach a large body of consumers, GlaxoSmithKline held a conference called the International Consensus Group on Depression and Anxiety, where they invited private scholars who “…could hold their own in the most sophisticated discussion of…the impact of globalization on the human mind” (Watters 515). They figured that in order to shift the Japanese society 's indifferent attitude with depression, one must first understand how it became perceived as such.…

    • 1586 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Third draft Humans have historically separated themselves to set their place in society. The dominance of mankind has constructed the expectations for humanity to complete our sense of security and self-importance. This is portrayed in two books, The island walkers by John Bemrose and The Kite Runner by Khaled Hosseini. Firstly, people have separated each other by distinguishing differences based on race.…

    • 1045 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Current Educational Issue Paper: “Ethnic Identity and Acculturative Stress as Mediators of Depression in Students of Asian Descent” In the article, “Ethnic Identity and Acculturative Stress as Mediators of Depression in Students of Asian Descent,” the matter of the well-being of college students of Asian descent--because these students had higher rates of depression is addressed (Lantrip, Mazzetti, Grasso, Gill, Miller, Haner, Rude & Awad, 2012). In my current college education, I can say that, like most other college students, I’ve experienced stress in both physically, mentally and emotionally. However, the research shown in this article is specific to those of Asian descent, including me, and how our culture affects our emotional state.…

    • 706 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Why follow the rules? Why not get what you want when you want it however you can get it? The mere function of today’s world is based on the elite necessity to have every citizen obey their laws. In addition, people never stop to ask themselves, “Why is there a pressing validity in the action of obeying wholesome rules, and how does this benefit me personally”? Thrasymachus addresses the underlining importance behind morality and the misleading advantages that follow with being virtuous.…

    • 1130 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Texts Set Assignment Text Name: The House on Mango Street by Sandra Cisneros What it's about: Chapter 4 focuses on Esperanza reflecting on her name. During the process, she reveals “marks” of her identity: how she identifies herself, what she values, where her family is from, and other topics that are relevant to this project. She talks about how she does not like her name and that others could pronounce it correctly.…

    • 936 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout history and up until our modern day, class conflict, violence, and the desire to dominate have always existed amongst human beings. The “fetish” of one group or sets of people depicting how “constructive structuralism” should look like and operate has contributed to the disparities within our society because of the ways in which we communicate with the general population. Many of the discontents and conflicts that exists in our world between different global hegemonies and globalization result from sudden political and/or economic changes which eventually influence social norms and culture values. Since these factors tend to be implemented by a group of people through the means of policies and division of labor, generational inheritances…

    • 756 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Friedrich Nietzsche on Master and Slave Morality,” an explication by Dr. John Armstrong, explains Friedrich Nietzsche's view on morality that argues Slave Morality is created to restrict “superior” people. To achieve such a claim, Armstrong compares and explains Master Morality and Slave Morality, and he further reveals the flaws of Slave Morality, “[the] artificial boundaries that constrain the strong from reaching their full potential” (5). Opening his analysis, Armstrong chronicles the history of Master and Slave Morality and informs the readers about Friedrich Nietzsche and his motivation for exploring the difference between these moralities. Armstrong reveals that Nietzsche, a philologist, values Master Morality over Slave Morality since it leads to the “peak of Western civilization” (1). Yet, many religions value Slave Morality instead.…

    • 777 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays