Difference Between Peasant And Tribal Society

Improved Essays
Social and cultural anthropology, examines different societies and cultures which therefore, presents similarities and differences within and among societies. When studying the main features of peasant and tribal societies, one notices their differences and similarities, in this case, focusing mainly on the economy and exchange of surplus, including their kinship and how their social relationships differ. The tribal society is one where the mode of production is for common use for the society while a peasant society’s mode of production is more isolated and surplus is transferred to a group of a higher status.
In a tribal society such as the Trobriands which were studied by Malinowski, production has both a physical side and a social side.
…show more content…
Eric Wolf describes peasants as ‘’rural cultivators whose surpluses are transferred to a dominant group of rulers that uses the surpluses both to underwrite its own standard of living and to the remainder to groups’’. There are different types of peasants: the feudal sector, independent smallholders and capitalist farmers. In the case of the feudal sector, land is owned by landlords who do not engage in cultivation but instead it is cultivated by others. Independent smallholders are peasants who own no more land than they can cultivate themselves and enough of it to make them self-sufficient. Lastly, capitalist farmers own substantial amounts of land and their farming is primarily based on the exploitation of wage labour. Patrilineages which are ‘’descent groups related through a common male lineage’’(Keesing), play significant roles in peasant social …show more content…
Due to their limited resources, there are chances of crop failure and they are forced to comply with demands from groups with a higher status. The peasants’ participation in the outside economy is restricted and directed, their economic activities are pressured and production is limited leading them to be isolated. The households act as separate corporations, as units of production and as competitors for income and scarce resources. Between families, there is competition and hostile distrust which is described as ‘atomism’. Opposed to tribal societies with strong kinship ties, the peasant society involves fictive kinship, this means that the social ties are neither through blood or marriage. An example of this is compadrazgo in Mexico. Foster describes ‘dyadic contracts’ in peasant societies, which is ‘’pairs of individuals are in many different spheres of life bound into relationships almost similar to contracts''. These ties vary; they can be between persons of equal status, some with patrons of a higher status who exploit each other for common advantage. The ties between superior status patrons outside the community aid in creating links into wider social

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The genealogical ties to social status are like a spider’s web, all interconnected, with the center as the main hub of power. The further away from the center, the least amount of relations to power are held. Tongan chiefdoms used a broad ranking system where seniority, gender, and sisterhood all factored into societal roles. These distinctions separated gender roles for food collecting, household duties and production of goods. Depending on the type of work or goods produced, the social class of the individual could be established.…

    • 1280 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Land's End Li describes the indigenous transformation of the Lauje due to their adoption of capitalist modes of production. Li frames the capitalist transformation of the Lauje primarily through the agricultural shift from swidden agriculture practices of crops of corn and rice fields, that were prevalent among the highland Lauje in the 1990's, to the enclosed farming of cacao and clove trees plot, which that had become the main “cash crops” by the 2006. Li adamantly shows how the Lauje readily embraced capitalist relations through cash crops, such as cacao, in an attempt “to join the march of progress promised in modernization narrative”(Li 2). The rapid emergence of the capitalist market brought with it equally rapid polarizing effects…

    • 278 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    My Shogunate Investigation Throughout Japan’s history men were valued higher than woman, and men were the favoured gender. Both women and men had different traditions, roles and responsibilities in society. During the Shogunate period (1550 - 1850), Japanese women were mothers, entertainers and even samurai warriors and the social hierarchy played an important role on woman’s freedom and determined their future in society. Women had certain duties to fulfil, and served many men during their lifetime.…

    • 1144 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The structures are depicted through the struggles the farmers have to face with job scarcity and low wages, and also through the banks seeking to gain power over the farms and land. A pure competitive market is when there many sellers…

    • 2159 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    This source provided helpful information regarding the Inca social system, enabling me to comprehend the Inca societal aspects at a deeper level. I was able to learn that the Incas divided their population into four social classes in very simple and logical terms, compared to that of other sources. Other references consisted of very complex and detailed explanations regarding the Inca vertical ladder, but never so brief and simply explained. Therefore, this source holds clear information that will aid me in my project. Furthermore, Discover Peru’s Inca Society article overviews concise and general information regarding the Ayullu commoners, in comparison to the intricate knowledge offered in other sources.…

    • 108 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mosuo Culture Analysis

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Conclusion In this paper, I have described The Mosuo culture using the Barrel Model. The Mosuo people are food foragers. They have a strange way of living their lives, but that makes their culture more exciting. They are a strict family orientated community that thrives on subsistence and social organization they believe in having countless children without knowing who the father is they just take care of each other.…

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “It’s Not You, It’s Me!” Despite there seems to be a tradition of oppression towards women found in most- if not all- societies. The oppression of women can be traced back into early civilizations, but why? The patriarchal society that is rooted in most countries is a form of inequality, favoring men over women.…

    • 1112 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The conflict theory is a perspective is derived from Karl Marx, who saw society as fragmented groups that compete for social and economic resources (Crossman). Social order is maintained with power, in the hands of those with the greatest political, social, and economic resources (Crossman). According to the conflict theory, inequality exists because of those in control of a disproportionate share of society’s recourses. Whereas most sociological theories focus on the positive aspects of society, the conflict perspective focuses on the negative, conflicted and ever-changing nature of society (Crossman). The documentary explains how women in impoverished villages in India are trying to break social norms and work together with their husbands in order to make family planning resources available and improve their status in villages.…

    • 811 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Without land to farm, many people are being forced to work as day laborers, fishing or building embankments. Some families are even being forced to abandon their…

    • 778 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Russian Peasantry

    • 169 Words
    • 1 Pages

    In The Russian Peasantry, Moon states that the peasants’ agricultural habits were based on an acute knowledge of their world. The peasants have continually been chided for resisting agricultural development whether in the form of tools, methods, or accepting new foodstuffs (like the potato) to grow. This decision, when better examined according to Moon, appears to have less to do with ignorant stubbornness and was actually based on what was reliable in Russia. The peasants simply could not afford to plant any untested crop or use new equipment for if it failed, it would force them to default on their obligations and more importantly cause famine. The old system, although archaic in other parts of the globe, was reliable in the eyes of the peasants.…

    • 169 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During the Neolithic period of ancient China it is believed that clans, multiple families who share the common name, were how the villages were differentiated, and that farming was the building block of society. Like most ancient cultures the ancient Chinese had a class system that they adhered to. This social structure was comprised of the king, the aristocratic elite, the peasants, the merchants, and the slaves. Yet again like most ancient cultures the two sexes had very separate distinct roles to play in society.…

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the midst of these inequalities, people were aware of the situation that the experiences presented (Harrison 147). The two economic extremes presented challenges and struggles between the villagers. One example of the differences was in accessing water and social integration between those who had a better economic life and the peasants. This is presented in the relationship between Miss Liu and the village of the Jinci village. In the midst of the society in the villages to keep up with life, the influence of modernity also crept in.…

    • 1463 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To grasp why the relationship between the men and women changed after the Agricultural Revolution, we should first get a brief outline of how the women were seen before the Revolution, and what part they played. With the assistance of archeologist and history recorded, we have the ability to differentiate the refinements in history of points of views of power between the men and women. There are three separate phases of human development in history: hunting and gathering, farming, and city life.1 The woman’s role changed in the midst of each of these stages. Preceding farming insurgency, amid the hunting and gathering stage, women had an imperative part in gathering and creating maintainability and safeguarding of sustenance.2 In the Paleolithic period they did not have private property and wealth, and they had no distinction in wealth and power, following every individual did a great deal of comparable work which was hunting and gathering.…

    • 1604 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Stemming back to my first question, there are a few practices in the Bhaca society that accelerate in changes. Some facets regarding to acceleration in the Bhaca involve the structural systems and patterning relationships of the tribe. The process of change is unable to be stopped, because the Bhaca are always involved with adjustments. The Bhaca show acceleration in their structural system since they are a small group of people that were known to do things together jointly, no matter what changes they had to overcome. I will first briefly mention how the Bhaca society is known to go through adjustments in their structural system.…

    • 2211 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Anthropologists have been trying to theorize the difference between culture and society since the founding days of the field. While doing this, patterns have arisen in both the differences and similarities of the two concepts, as well as their relationship to technology. Through a thorough reading of the Wolf and Keesing articles there exists fundamental differences between culture and society. As Keesing states “Cultures are a system of shared ideas. Thus, culture can be referred to as an ideational system” (p.24).…

    • 1110 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays