The Western Medical Model: A Case Study

Improved Essays
Part 1

Introduction

Throughout the world there are universals of medical systems that pertain to all healing systems. These universals include a) integral part of the culture relating to a particular view of the body and the cosmos; b) has illness causation explanations; c) has diagnostic method and tools; d) has healers; e) has helpers; and, f) has treatments for both preventing and curing. The six universals vary from medical system to medical system, making each one unique. In this essay, the western medical model specifically will be used in contrast to Curanderismo and Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) practices. Through the different cultures, we will show a distinction of how the six universals are used and their use of personalistic
…show more content…
Curanderas, a term that is as varied with the Hispanic culture as are the methods these women use to cure (Perrone, 1989, p.85) Within its own form there are different methods due to the various regions this is practiced. Through the different types of Curanderas as stated from Pamela Godde’s lectures include Curandera total, Parteras (midwives), Sobardoras (massage specialists), and Yerberas (herbalists). Curandera total is the highest position on the hierarchal Hispanic ladder of healing (Perrone, 1989, p.90). A partera is a midwife, but she may also use herbs during the course of her prenatal care. Sobardoras heal with their hands and supplement their efforts with herbal medications when appropriate but rely more on acupressure applied to the affected areas for results than on curative properties of herbs to alleviate their patient’s ailments. As mentioned it is a complex system of folk medicine with its own theoretical, diagnostic and therapeutic aspects (Perrone, 1989, …show more content…
As for someone who would be interested in practicing Western medicine, it would require them to do many years of schooling before starting their work. There is a similarity in types of illnesses between the two because they both treat those with physical, mental social and psychosocial. The difference is the root of the issue for curanderas would find it coming from a spiritual imbalance in their patient. In Western medicine, the causes of their patient’s illness would come internally from a certain imbalance in their body. Aside from their diagnosis and treatment the major difference would be through the help that each gets. The way in which patients are treated by curanderas through herbs or through a spiritual healing is similar in a sense to how Western medicine treats patients through different medications. Curanderas call on help from the spiritual world through saints and God to give them the power of healing. Whereas in Western Medicine they have helpers like nurses or other specialists that would be involved with helping treat their patients. Apart from the differences they both have one focus which is helping others get

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    There are several social determinants that effect the community’s wellbeing and they generally fall within the board categories of policymaking, social factors, healthcare services, and individual lifestyle and behavior. Social determinants play a crucial role in an individual’s heath and the community’s well being. Inequalities in social determinants often are what cause an individual to suffer poor health, which causes the wellbeing of the community to suffer as well. After reading The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down, I believe that culture is a major social determinant that affects not just the health of the individual but also the health of the community. The book also adds that we do not have a good grasp on how to examine context as in the case of Lia she was treated by American medical practices but her cultural background was ignored.…

    • 1246 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In the United States, many doctors face the challenge of working with patients that are of a different race or ethnicity from him or herself. Along with that, these patients are left confused and with a sense of powerlessness when working with American doctors. It becomes very hard to communicate not only because of a distinct language barrier, but also a cultural barrier. Many cultures approach situations in different ways, especially in regard to medical care. The book, The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down, by Anne Fadiman, is a story about a Hmong family who seeks treatment in the United States for their daughter Lia.…

    • 1591 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Introduction: This essay will assess how cultural differences impacted Lia Lee's health in the book The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down by Anne Fadiman. It will point to several different times when cultural disagreements lead to distinct negative or positive effects on Lia’s health. It will also show how, despite overcoming almost all of the cultural disagreements amongst the Hmong and American doctors, Lia’s health still failed. A counter argument claiming that the doctors hold more responsibility than the Lee’s for Lia’s declining health is also provided and rebuked.…

    • 1590 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1. Describe the primary issues presented in the case study. The case study of the doctor in the sleep study clinic represents issues with health disparities, race, poverty/socioeconomic class, ethnicity and culture. The doctor clearly puts his own needs first as well as remains at the job due to its proximity to family and friends.…

    • 925 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The tragedy that befell Lia Lee, a Hmong child, was a result of a power struggle between the Hmong and western medicine physicians, cultural impasse, and a conflict between who knows what’s best for Lia. It was too late before cultural medical reform occurred that doctors were beginning to view the person with the symptoms rather than the symptoms a person has. The Hmong were on one end of the spectrum where they believed that problems of the soul manifested themselves in the body and so spiritual healing was the best form of treatment. On the other end, the doctors believed that health problems were strictly biological and should be treated with pharmaceuticals. The distance between these two sides is what led to multiple disagreements…

    • 1214 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The ability to experience pain and suffering are universally and innately part of human ideology. Margaret Lock and Nancy Scheper-Hughes situate human affliction as mutually constructed by biological, social, and cultural understandings of the body. Both anthropologists advocate for a comprehensive perspective regarding illness and disease in which knowledge of and explanatory models referring to an individual’s illness are fixed on a greater social, political, and cosmic influences. Apparent identical life events can be explained by purely contradictory understandings of the body; pain, suffering and death simply cannot be explained in a manner that lacks the wider context of culture and society.…

    • 1213 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Western medicine is primarily the medicine that all of North America and Western Europe are under the general care of. A large part of the population is oblivious to the way Western Medicine has everyone stuck in a trap of epic disaster. The collective actions of modern medicine will slowly build up antibiotic resistance, weaken immune systems and will eventually cause complete mutation of mindset when people are unaware how to function without having a quick fix pill for their health problem. Rather than the traditional doctors of Western Medicine being required to have training in nutrition, they instead spend hundreds of frivolous hours studying and memorizing symptoms and treatments to the body's system of interworking organs.…

    • 347 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Essay On Hmong Culture

    • 2194 Words
    • 9 Pages

    The cultural clashes amongst the people of the Hmong and Westered based society of America about health care is a clash of ideologies and ethnocentrism. A refusal to find middle ground and a general misunderstanding of each other’s cultures. Each of these culture’s healing arts, be that biomedicine of America or the traditional healings of the Hmong, are working remedies that tackle the problems faced by healers and doctors with a unique understanding of one’s culture. Through the Hmong it is a spiritual and a truly holistic understanding of the body, while the American biomedicine divides things into parts, like a car. These two systems while approaching the same field with different understandings, can have similar results.…

    • 2194 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Response and Summary to “How Do We Heal Medicine” In Atul Gawande’s speech “How do we heal medicine”, the speaker assertively claims that healing medicine requires us to embrace different values from the ones we've had, like humility, discipline, teamwork. A good system was also required for reaching the new values. At the beginning of his speech, Gawande explained how is medicine system changed over the time. Not only by providing present and past data and analyzing those data, but also using Lewis Thomas’ book, “The Youngest Science” as a reference for his audience to under the difference of being a doctor between now and post.…

    • 795 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Cultural Considerations

    • 963 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Ethnic, Genetic, and Cultural Considerations in Prescribing Providers are accountable to be culturally competent, empathetic and knowledgeable with treatment options for patients. The following paper addresses pharmacotherapeutics, client compliance and advanced nursing practice. Also highlighted will be resources available to clinicians and how to educate a client on the identification or prevention of potential pharmacodynamics or pharmokinetic problems. Ethnic, Genetic and Cultural Considerations More than 1000 medications have ingredients that may be prohibited in various religions and cultures (Hoesli & Smith, 2011). In addition to religious beliefs, other factors may play a part in medication use such as a vegetarian lifestyle…

    • 963 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Pain and suffering is considered a part of the life and death cycle, so it is not unusual for people who are dying in pain. Religion plays an important part in the Mexican culture, so prayers is often used to give hope to the sick. Mexicans believe that someone giving the infant or child the” evil eye” causes them sickness and the spell is broken only when that person touches the infant or child (Giger & Davidhizar, 2013). Mexicans do not believe they have control over their health. They believe that death is an unpreventable phenomenon and God determines the cause of one’s death.…

    • 774 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Health Promotion Concepts Define concepts Health Defining the word and meaning of health can be both complex and challenging. The concept that health is a state of being without disease or illness does not encompass all the variables that make up an individual’s “health. According to the World Health Organization (WHO) “health is a state of complete physical, mental and social well-being and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity” (1948). Well-being: Health can be seen as a person’s overall wellbeing.…

    • 1113 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Healthcare is a universal need. People around the world need healthcare to make sure they stay in perfect health. To stay perfectly healthy people needs access to doctors, nurses, and other health professionals including health information management to evaluate and document their healthcare diagnosis and care. However, health professional has experience some issues when it comes to take care of people’s health. One of the main issues that many health care providers face is the wide variety of diversity of their patient’s culture and beliefs.…

    • 848 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    His theory provides a paradigmatic solution to an existential crisis. In the case of Lia Lee, it is not just that the Lee’s did not understand the words of the doctors. Their religion, and hence the way that they see the world, did not have the conceptual framework to understand Western medical practice. Just as non-religious man does not always understand religious man’s cosmology. Lia Lee’s family struggled to negotiate a balance between the demands of their traditional beliefs and modern medicine.…

    • 1392 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Brilliant Essays

    Vodou Case Study

    • 2113 Words
    • 9 Pages
    • 16 Works Cited

    As McCarthy Brown (2003) noted, healers “rarely try to compete with scientific medicine” (p.285). In fact, more often the practitioner, once he has appeased the problem with the supernatural, advises the client to consult Western biomedicine to repair the remaining damage from the Vodou spirits former wrath (Freeman, 2007, p.125). In this view Vodou is essentially enlisted to combat the cause and biomedicine to combat the symptoms. Although, as Freeman (2007) notes “in practice, real collaboration has been limited to working with midwives, injectionists and faith and herb healers, with in a few cases strictly voodoo practitioners called in for certain psychotherapeutic counseling”…

    • 2113 Words
    • 9 Pages
    • 16 Works Cited
    Brilliant Essays