Nagel Subjective Nature Analysis

Improved Essays
Introduction To understand the idea of subjective and objective nature and how it functions in human experience, it becomes critical to understand that “greater objectivity” does us no good in understand subjectivity. I will explore this passage of Nagel and the rest of the reading to explain why subjectivity and physicalism do not correspond and how this influences Nagel’s thoughts on physicalism. Then, I will reflect on how I believe the world would become a better place if we really could access other’s subjective nature even though we are not capable of this task.
Analysis
In the following passage, Nagel discusses how objective experience and subjective character correlate: The idea of moving from appearance to reality seems to
…show more content…
It actually reduces our chances of access. This relates to his idea of consciousness of “what it is like to be that organism,” since we as humans will never know what it is like to be another human, animal, or being because we cannot fundamentally change to another conscious (Nagel, What is it like to Be a Bat?, 221). Though objective experience may broaden our viewpoint of a particular subject, it does not allow us to access the truth to a subjective character. Nagel believes that the movement to reality from appearances would be pointless because of the mere fact that it would be moving towards the same thing just in a different way that is more objective. Moving towards greater objectivity is usually the aim to understanding things better since it gets us to how something actually is aside from how each person’s perspective perceives it. But, because this passage is pertaining to the subjective nature of experience, greater objectivity does, according to Nagel, us no good. He says, “that concerns the same thing” to prove his point. When we focus one one phenomenon and how we understand it, no matter how objective our viewpoints become, the phenomenon can still only be understood in the same manner as when we began discerning it. This is because the subjective nature is in the thing itself, thus we must become the entity …show more content…
As I was analyzing this passage I started to really ponder about this and I immediately thought of racism and how we treat people. Nagel completely disagrees with Physicalism because it does not take subjectivity into account and I feel like he would agree that physicalism creates discrimination. Blacks, latinos, asians, and other ethnicities are commonly thought of as minorities of the world to whites and only because of their physical differences. If humans were able to access other’s subjective point of view then maybe racism would not be such a prominent issue. Humans would see that every single person has the same subjective ability to feel and would finally understand that there are no superior races in the world. I am entirely on board with Nagel’s points against physicalism as it pertains to an issue that is important to me. Discrimination of any type is just wrong and I wish that people could “see” past physical differences to tackle this terrible

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Struggles with Awareness To be fully real, one must first be recognized by another person of equal or higher prestige in society. Only through proving one’s self, can such awareness be achieved. In a typical Hegelian struggle, two equal opponents face one another and battle for dominance. One will succeed and become the Master, and one will fall short to become the Bondsman.…

    • 790 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    What is the capacity in which things that are not under your control can affect the amount of moral responsibility that you face? For this topic, there are generally three main views that claim to answer this question, and they are each rather simple; first, there are those that think that people are only blameworthy for things that are under their control. Second, there are those who think that people are blameworthy for things that are not under their control, and lastly, there are those that restrict the second view, such that they can compromise between both views. In this paper, I will discuss the first two views only, providing arguments for the second view as well as possible counterarguments from those that think the first view is correct.…

    • 1287 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    William Del Fresno There are many questions that plague all of human existence. Questions which have no definite answer, and most likely never will in the span of all our lifetimes. Questions such as how do we know anything? Is there a thing as free will? And perhaps the largest of them all, what is the meaning of life?…

    • 2266 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The meaning to one’s existence is a constant search for mankind. In their lifetimes they experience various events that transform their views on the world. In turn changing their view of their very own existence. In John Gardner’s Grendel, Grendel’s perspective of himself in a mindless and mechanical natural world, illustrates the idea that one’s perspective on existence stems from experience. Grendel’s surroundings and various encounters help shape his view of an indifferent and unsympathetic natural world.…

    • 1127 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Compare and contrast Camus’s, Nagel’s, and the existentialist’s (as set out by Sartre and De Beauvoir) positions on the meaning and value of human life. Which is the best supported position (be sure to give reasons for your judgment), and what problems does it still face? How might it respond to these problems? In this essay I will compare and contrast Camus’s, Nagel’s, and the existentialists’, specifically Sartre and De Beauvoir, positions on the meaning and value of human life.…

    • 1182 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    With that in mind, humans are more prone to judge what they see rather than getting in to know someone or learn about something as it is easier and less time consuming which can be seen as a flaw in human nature. By judging only what you can see, it can cause the inability to see past the physical…

    • 1268 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    He yearns to reduce this entire thing in materialistic terms, yet still preserving the humanistic qualities. He does this by stating mental states are identical with physical states. Although they have this relationship mental states are identical inner states and behavior is an outer state. Thus, this means that if one targets the correct area of the brain he can eliminate these mental states leaving being an animal of stimuli. All of these perspectives shed an illuminating light on the issues of physicalism and dualism which is to be debated for years to come.…

    • 1625 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Thomas Nagel Volunteer

    • 1835 Words
    • 8 Pages

    I. Not too long ago I decided it was important that I took on more volunteer work in my life. Throughout the past two summers I dedicated myself to volunteering for at least eight hours a week. Upon telling one of my friends about the volunteer position she blatantly asked what my purpose was in dedicating myself to volunteer work. She made sure to note my actions will have little significance later in my life. My first reaction was astonishment; I had never thought that one individual could think so negatively of such a positive action.…

    • 1835 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I believe that Nagel 's primary conclusion in “What is it like to be a bat?” is that while there are multiple different forms of consciousness, humans cannot be sure of the presence of consciousness in lesser forms of animals, such as a bat. The “what it is like” for Nagel is reworded as being subjective character. The bat has subjective character, which is experience. Even though we know that bats hang upside down, have webbed arms and feet, and use echolocation, we will never truly know what it is like to be a bat. While we can all have thoughts on what it is like to be a bat, Nagel states that because everything has its own interpretation of itself, there is no way we can add specific information into our minds to actually see what it is…

    • 733 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Hypothesis of Phenomenal Information is incompatible with physicalism, but the Ability Hypothesis is compatible and, therefore, should be preferred. A possible objection to physicalism may be that propositional knowledge can be acquired through first person experiences just like ability knowledge…

    • 1723 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Appearance is how objects seem to be to us and it is subjective. Reality on the other hand, is how objects actually are in themselves, apart from any observers, and it is objective. To better explain what is subjective, take in consideration the following example; when the people wary of The Matrix are eating, they joke about the fact that whatever it is they are tasting is in fact virtual and only their mind generating ideas about the savor. Therefore, in actuality, the taste is artificial and there is no true taste. Even if there was, nobody can explain for sure what exactly it is that they savor.…

    • 1372 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Hegel who is a German philosopher and an important figure of German idealism believes that consciousness of objects mention some awareness of self, as a subject, which is isolated from the recognized object. But Hegel argue that subjects are also objects when we look at the other subjects. In ‘the Phenomology of Spirit’, he tries to point out that self-consciousness is the awareness of another individual’s understanding of oneself. One of the most important pieces he wrote is called the dialectic of the master and slave. In today’s world, there are many social conflict that can be analyzed by the help of the perspective of Hegel’s master slave dialectic.…

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    If there was one article that really stuck out to me throughout the semester, it has to be Nagel’s “What Is It Like to Be a Bat”. It’s concept and philosophy fixed itself into me and I tried applying those ideas to other articles as we went on. This article addresses one of the big questions of consciousness that tends to float around when discussing philosophy, which is what is it like to be something other than yourself? It isn’t too often that you debate on whether or not something or someone is experiencing the same feelings obtained through the environment as you are.…

    • 1348 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Dualism Vs Physicalism

    • 1103 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The view of physicalism gives a stronger and more plausible answer to the mind-body problem. There are several reasons why this particular view gives a more sensible for answer to the problem at hand. These reasons include the rationale behind the reasoning of brain research, how the different aspects of reductive physicalism is able to address the non-physical aspects of the mind, as well as the less than sensible claims that the opposing view, dualism, presents in comparison. One of the main reasons why physicalism is able to prove itself to be the better answer to the mind-body problem is based off of research that society has learned about on the brain.…

    • 1103 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The meaning of life is a highly controversial topic among humans; one that has been debated for centuries. A particular philosopher, Thomas Nagel, has a certain idea about what the meaning of life. However, I do not agree with his position. Essentially, he believed that life has no meaning and that there is no rationale that could be given to it in order to make it meaningful. Nevertheless, even if everything we do in life will be forgotten, that does not mean humans cannot find meaning in their everyday life.…

    • 908 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays