Critical Analysis Of Katherine Boo's Behind The Beautiful Forever

Improved Essays
In the previous critical analysis on the first few chapters of Katherine Boo’s novel, ‘Behind the Beautiful Forever’, discussions were related to the general socioeconomic constraints slum dwellers face in Mumbai. This second critical analysis of chapters five through eight will focus specifically on the development obstacles of a young Muslim slum dweller, which led a simple argument amongst neighbors to result in a false conviction. While the method of discerning the development obstacles is one often used in ‘International Development’ course, the novels content will again be paired with the theoretical content present in the ‘Development and the City’ course to date. Connected to the events associated with the burning of a disabled women, topics such as natural …show more content…
While the city is home to a major financial cluster, which tends to make a city more resilient, there are glaring inequalities. This can be easily understood when reading Boo’s novel as comparisons between the slum dwellers and the rest of the city are stark. What many do not take note of, however, is that inequalities are also present amongst slum dwellers that can lead to dramatic actions done in envy, like setting oneself on fire. In this scenario it is understood that Fatima, a disabled women was envious of the current success the Husain family was having economically. After lighting herself on fire, “on arrival at Cooper [hospital], Fatima had said that Karam, Abdul, and Kahkashan had set her on fire”, a lie told to ruin the family . Reading, it was hard to believe someone would be willing to go to such extreme measure to ruin another family. Nevertheless, while some people aspire to achieve more in witnessing the cities rapid economic growth others have been crushed by experiences of destitution leaving them feeling that they have nothing to

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    They should also cooperate to request for redistribution and to achieve reformations such as universalization of health care. Boo does an excellent job of making her book sound interesting, making the nonfiction work easy to follow along. She provides detailed descriptions of objects such as garbage, which make the readers able to have a vivid imagination that allows them to feel empathy. However, although Boo’s book provides a detailed story on the lives of the slum-dwellers, it lacks a comparison target. Boo could have interviewed people who live outside of the slums because this would have been helpful to the readers in figuring out the level of inequality through measurements such as the Gini…

    • 794 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Inspirational, uplifting, and informational are three words I choose to describe the memoir: Becoming Ms. Burton wrote by Cari Lynn and Susan Burton. It’s not every day you get the chance to read a book that is able to enhance your own perspective on life, but Ms. Burton’s book did just that. The story, Ms. Burton’s story, give reader’s a major glimpse into the life of a woman suffering from her unearned disadvantages and the consequences that are tied to those disadvantages. The beginning of the story starts with Susan, Ms. Burton’s former self, and takes the reader’s on a journey through Susan’s life full of hardships from growing up in a crime-ridden neighborhood, to her introduction to crack cocaine. As the book moves forward, Susan’s story evolves into a bigger story that is connected to multiple social problems such as poverty, abuse, and racial discrimination in the justice system.…

    • 743 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many people living in a poor neighborhood wish to not stay there long. Such an idea is understandable because they want to leave behind a life they are ashamed of and live a life they can be proud of and show off. In her novel, Sandra Cisneros shows what a life of poverty and disappointments can be like. Through the work, we watch the main character always wish of a house to have of her own and not to live a life she is ashamed of. Throughout the novella, it is easy to see that a significant theme of the novella is people often dislike where they live when society has judged them .…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    “Squatter” is a creative and simultaneous meditation on the effects of cultural differentiation and the experiences faced by migrants as they try to fit into foreign societies. The story has an overall toilet-related subject wit and Mistry uses the theme to create a story that reflects on the shortcomings of relocation. It further offers a cynical view of the impacts of cultural variances on a person’s psyche and identity. “Squatter” is a narrative that combines two stories that Nariman Hansotia tells to the boys in the Mumbai neighborhood. The first story features a gifted sportsman, Savushka, and the second one is about a eponymous young squatter known as Sarosh.…

    • 1150 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Segregation is the separation of humans into racial groups in daily life. Throughout history in multi-racial communities segregation has always existed. It can be found anywhere from in school to in the work place. In Jennifer Baszile’s “The Black Girl Next Door” we witness the difficulties Jen and her family have integrating into the white upper class neighbourhood in the year of 1975. This is shown through Jen’s anger, betrayal and naivety, her mom’s teacher-like approach vs. her dad’s business man like approach as well as the social and religious symbols displayed throughout the story.…

    • 811 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Huntington claims that hard-working men and women leading noble and pure lives are just as present in tenement-houses as feeble minded and corrupt people. Jacob A. Riis claims that generations degrade in the slums because of “the influences that prevail there” (Riis “The Problem of the Children” 1892). This environment is not only degrading, but can be the only way of life. “The road to ruin, as we call it, is so fatally easy to them; who shall dare to blame them if they take it?” (Edgar Fawcett “The Woes of the New York Working-Girl” 1891).…

    • 1637 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Michael Perry, the author, once expressed, “Never mock a pain you have never endured or judge a situation you have never been in.” As illustrated, it is wrong to judge someone based on their life experiences. The theme of House on Mango Street is prejudgment, it proves the point that to prejudge someone is unfair, because contributing factors in everyday lives of many people are uncontrollable such as income class, gender, and race. Starting off, to prejudge someone based on their social class is unfair, considering it is an uncontrollable factor in their life. Throughout the vignette, “The House on Mango Street”, the author characterized Esperanza’s house by saying, “ Paint peeling, wooden bars papa had nailed on the windows so we wouldn’t…

    • 710 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Thesis Statement: The novel “Lullabies for little criminals," written by Heather O’ Neill, examines the effect of social determinants which are poverty and homelessness on the main character Baby’s life. Poverty interwinds with homelessness in Baby’s life, building an insecure childhood for her to grow up with. Introduction: According to my thesis statement, I will explain how poverty restricts baby’s living expectation at first and the relationship between limited living expectation and homelessness will be discussed after that.…

    • 890 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The quote, “They ain’t rich folks. Rich folks don’t try so hard.” , explains how Aibileen learns that the Leefolts are less well off than they seem. This passage makes it clear for the reader to understand that usually, people who come from wealth, do not have to work to the extremes that people of lower classes do because they have people that do their work for them. When Aibileen remembers the shame she felt after being fired on the first day of her job as a maid, “Shame ain’t black like dirt, like I always thought it was.…

    • 1131 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Another social factor that is impacting many individuals around the world and characters in Nickel and Dimed is food insecurity. According to the article, “Annually, 39 million persons experience food insecurity, Food insecurity is defined as having limited or uncertain availability of nutritionally adequate and safe foods or ability to acquire foods in a acceptable way” (pg 71). This quote exhibits that large number of people face food instability meaning that they don’t have or have enough safe and healthy food to intake. An individual might believe that people who have a job should be able to feed themselves. In reality many face difficulties choosing whether to feed themselves or paying the rent in which choosing to pay the rent becomes…

    • 1820 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Societal Shackles Within today’s society, the oppressive forces of societal norms seem to constrict many lesser privileged members of the population. More and more frequently, there are outcries for a revision of the current way of life; movements such as feminism exemplify these reforms. So many people nowadays, and all throughout history, feel trapped by society due to prejudices held against them or due to their socio-economic standing. In literature, when one believes one is trapped, it often reveals a divide wherein one is trapped either figuratively or literally.…

    • 1891 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Carol B. Stack’s book, All Our Kin, reiterates Stack’s personal experience in The Flats, an African-American poverty-stricken community. Stack observes the black urban poor and how they try to survive while living in poverty. Stack believes that when other researchers study black communities, their findings have a tendency to reinforce and perpetuates stereotypes such as they are deviant, matriarchal, and broken. Stack’s findings, however does reinforce and perpetuates the stereotypes among the black community. Stack provides numerous of evidences that show that the urban black poor are in such a situation due their environment, but in the end she is also reinforcing the “deviant, matriarchal, and broken” stereotypes amongst black communities.…

    • 914 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    “Racism is still with us. But it is up to us to prepare our children for what they have to meet, and, hopefully, we shall overcome.” ~Rosa Parks. The roots of racism have passed down through generations because parents force their children to follow racial traditions in order for them to continue those norms for future generations.…

    • 1529 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The word “character” derives from the Greek word , “kharakter” meaning engraved mark, also known as a symbol or imprint on the soul. In Cheryl Strayed essay “The Love of My Life” Strayed is a vacillating grieving daughter who begins to lose herself within all the grief. Moreover, Strayed uses three prime ways to exhibit her character prominently to the reader. Her choice of relationships, emotions, and usage of diction cogently depicts her character throughout the essay.…

    • 776 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Classism; unfair treatment due to one’s social or economic class. One is treated differently based on their social class; lower, upper, or higher class. The treatment of each class can be unfair, as society gives each class different amounts of respect. The discrimination one feels due to their class can stop their progress in various ways, which all in all prevents them from realizIng their full ability. The lower class is often discriminated as they are looked down at and others feel superior to them.…

    • 1118 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays