Compare And Contrast England's Settlement In The Americas To Spain

Improved Essays
Compare and contrast England’s settlement history in the Americas to Spain’s. Consider the treatment of Indians, the role of the Church, the significance of women, and economic development.
The role of the Church had to do with both England and Spain’s settlement history, with the Spanish trying to win souls for the pope in Rome and defend Catholicism, whereas the English believed that they had to free the native peoples from the tyranny of Spain and Rome. Foner writes, “England expressed its imperial ambitions in terms of an obligation to liberate the new world from the tyranny of the pope.” Also England had no desire to conquer the indigenous people, they just wanted to displace them to get to their land, as opposed to the Spaniards who wished to intermarry, organize their labor, and make them subjects of the Spanish crown. However, while the English were not conquerors, they did displace more of the Native American population than that of any other empire.
For the English, land was the basis of liberty. Explain the reasoning behind the concept and how it was markedly different from the Indians conception of land.
The concept is quite simple, land gave individuals power. The owning of land allowed men the
…show more content…
Further, they policed their own actions heavily holding that idleness and immoral behavior were signs of evil. Foner writes, “All Puritans shared many of the beliefs of the Church of England and the society as a whole, including a hatred for Catholicism and a pride in England’s greatness as a champion of liberty. But they believed that neither the Church nor the nation was living up to its ideals” if they shared such a burning hatred for the Church of England and Catholicism then one can only imagine how intolerant they would be towards the

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Not all colonists in New England were Puritans but the Puritan religion was a major influence on the establishment of the colonies. Puritans were not satisfied with the Protestant Reformation and believed that the Church of England had to many Catholic rituals. They believed neither the church nor the nation were living up to their ideals. In order to seek the truth they urged the people to read the Bible and listen to their sermons. Puritans followed the teachings of John Calvin in which he taught that the world was divided between the elect and the damned.…

    • 1227 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article “The Treatment of the Indians in Plymouth Colony” written by David Busnell, focuses on the issues the Indians face with the English colonists around the 1600’s. Bushnell frequently discusses the negotiations of land and trade of goods between the Indians and English Colonists. Most importantly, he specifies how the trade and negotiations came about and how they were settled. The content in the article shows the controversial relationship of the English colonists and Indians through a series of confusing purchases of land, what both groups of people valued as currency and their representation in the colony.…

    • 932 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Spanish, French, and Dutch colonies in North America all interacted with the Native Americans during the 16th century. Spain’s extreme subjugating approach and views on freedom and religion differed from the accepting and collaborative views of the French and the Dutch. Although the French and Dutch had apparent positive approaches compared to Spain, oppression of the Native Americans occurred under the control of all three colonies. The Spanish were the first to colonize North America and their approach lacked moral compass.…

    • 708 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The English and Spanish differences during the Age of Exploration within their government, religion, and economy led to many advantages and disadvantages that changed the New World’s fate. The Spanish were the first to arrive to North America, and mainly wanted to explore. They were motivated by gold, glory, and god. Their government was tight, watched strictly, and rich.…

    • 629 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    a) Briefly explain, with reference to TWO of the factors listed below, how there came together in Europe in the early 16th century both the motivation and the means to explore and colonize land across the seas. Religion conflicts arose between the Protestants and the Catholics. The Catholics of Spain and Portugal, along with the Protestants of England and Holland, acquired a desire to spread their versions of Christianity to other people as a result of religious rivalries. Religion also provided the means for exploration. The monarchs in Spain were Catholic.…

    • 1127 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Kanong Vang The New Atlantic World During the colonial period, Europeans and Africans arrived to the Americas. Europeans in the fifteenth century did not have the necessary tools and economic resources to overcome the wilderness. However, when Europeans and Africans arrived to the New World they did not find wilderness but a civilization that has been created many years before already by the Native Americans. “Even in places that Europeans regarded as primordial wilderness there is evidence that native peoples engineered landscapes to support their populations (Video Lecture, Pre-Columbian America).”…

    • 1145 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Colonial America Dbq

    • 740 Words
    • 3 Pages

    From the colonial period through the early Republic, Americans shared a desire for liberty and equality, two dreams complexly linked together, requiring attentiveness from all citizens to maintain a balance, which proved to be a delicate task, regardless of the time-period. Colonial Period English colonization in the Americas during the colonial period, 1492-1750, made up of two distinct groups, those in search of religious freedom and persecution, and those interested in new land and fortunes. Liberty for early colonials meant freedom from their jobless and landless mother country of England. In fact, many viewed America in the early seventeenth century as a land of opportunity; so much in fact, Europeans were willing to risk the tumultuous…

    • 740 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    While Spain’s colonization did go about as a conquest, England’s colonization had been simply just that, colonization. In fact, England had promoted all kinds of civilians to take up residence in their colonies, from criminals to Puritans. Nevertheless, the effects of their colonizing were similar, if not identical. Englishmen pilgrimaging to America, whether Puritan, Protestant, Baptist, Catholic, or Quaker, differed the only minusculely from Spaniards’ robust Catholicism when concerning what to do with pagan ideas.…

    • 805 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The New England and the Chesapeake region were both settled by people of English origin, but developed into completely different societies. They did not have the same intentions for their settlement in the New World. The colonies had religious, political, economic and social differences. New England sought religious freedom, however, in the Chesapeake region when the people first settled all they wanted to do was look for gold and other valuables to take back to Europe. New England sent families with children and servants and Virginia did not.…

    • 774 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The New World was a land full of choices for the settlers that discovered it to make. Despite the fact that the Spanish and English people came into the New World at different time frames, both countries had goals to achieve. The English wanted to establish settlements for a growing future nation, and the Spanish wanted gold and success in expansion as well. The Spanish and New England colonies in the New World in 1492-1763 had both major differences and similarities in government, religion, and the treatment of indigenous people.…

    • 1153 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Directly following the start of the Commercial Revolution in the 1400s, Spain and England began to colonize the Americas, which was often referred to as the New World. The Spanish and English colonies were both similar and different in several ways. The Spanish and English colonies were slightly alike in the poor and unfair treatment of indigenous people and substantially different in religion and economic base. The Spanish and English were slightly comparable in terms of treatment of indigenous people because of enslavement of native people and taking their land.…

    • 1632 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In 1492, Christopher Columbus, an Italian explorer, initiated colonization by Europe in the New World when he sailed across the Atlantic Ocean to the Americas. English and Spanish colonies grew to become very different from one another with frequent similarities. The Spanish colonies and New England greatly differed in terms of control by a European government, were both vastly similar and extremely different in terms of religion, and were largely similar in terms of treatment of indigenous people. The Spanish colonies and New England were slightly similar and greatly different in terms of control by European government due to supporting their European country and their acceptance of European religion.…

    • 2387 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    By the late seventeenth century, much of Native American land was considered to be controlled and owned by the English crown. The only way an Indian could own property was to get a land grant from the King (Cronon 70). Once a European settler owned land, they were encouraged to “…transform the soil by a property system that taught them to treat land as capital” (Cronon 77). Cronon states a very important aspect to European land ownership in that the owner of an area of land must improve it and tend to their property for the land remain in their custody. Since Native American homes were easily…

    • 1758 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Marvels of Spain- And America As expressed in Wayne Franklin’s “The Beginnings of 1700” chapter, “The Marvels of Spain- And America” Franklin, regards the changes in the the New World as the Europeans, namely Christopher Columbus in the year 1492, colonize and, “the Indians soon had a colonial imitation of Europe developing before their eyes, complete with fortresses, churches, houses, new foods,” and more (4). Just as Spaniards were in awe of the, “trees of a thousand kinds” and “birds of many kinds and fruits of great diversity” as described in Diego Mendez’s letter to Ferdinand, natives are shocked as foreigners come and try to tame a land that had been wild and plentiful to their population for many years before the arrival of the colonists (26). The Spaniards are quick to bring scores of their population over to this “New World” to take advantage of…

    • 1616 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    The Puritan Movement

    • 1125 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Although the Puritan society has become synonymous with strictness and death, its society and ideals have influenced culture throughout history. The origins of Puritanism can be traced back to the Protestant reformation and their separation from the church of England. The Puritans believed that the Church of England needed to be purified, that the church leaders had too much power and that it should be more evenly distributed throughout the church body. In the 1560s due to their beliefs, the Protestant reformers collectively become known as Puritans for their belief in the necessity for the purification of the church. These reformers soon left for the Americas to build what many described as "a city on the hill."*cite?…

    • 1125 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays