Commonwealth V Western Australia Case Study

Improved Essays
.The division of power in Australia is the principle that sovereignty should be divided between the federal government and the state government, an example of this would be the case of the Commonwealth v Western Australia (1999) This case involved the implementation of the Mining Act 1978 (WA) to an area in Western Australia that under Defence Force regulations had been asserted as a defence practice area.The Commonwealth petitioned to the High Court for declarations that Mining Wardens do not have jurisdiction to consider applications for mining tenements over the land. The the Mining Act does not apply to the land within the defence practice area and so the Act does not bind the Commonwealth.The Court held that, the Mining Act does not, as a matter of construction, apply to freehold or leasehold land vested in the Commonwealth and therefore does not apply to land of this kind within the defence practice area. The separation of power …show more content…
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander law is based on tradition, ritual and socially acceptable conduct. This is known as customary law. In 1999 Indigenous sentencing courts were introduced, they do not apply customary law but they do enable representatives of the Indigenous community to have a say in the ruling. In some courts, traditional customs have a more dramatic impact on sentencing, particularly in the Northern Territory. In the case of R v Wunungmurra the defendant was convicted of assault against his wife. The sentencing court had an affidavit of Ms Laymba Laymba, and elder from the offenders community. She stated that the offender is a Dalkaramirri, a senior person within the clan. It is his role to enforce traditional law, this included corporal punishment on his wife. In her view, he was acting in accordance with this law. However the prosecution declared that Ms Laymba Laymba’s affidavit did not provide any explanation for the defendant’s actions, Denis Wunungmurra was sentenced to four and a half years

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    VICTORIAN CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATION TRIBUNAL (VCAT) The Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT)is organized under the Victoria Civil And Administrative Tribunal Act 1998 and it started functioning on the date of 1st July 1998.VCAT has 15 boards and tribunals to offer and conducts hearings in some areas in Victoria specifically in suburban and regional. Its location was in 55 King street,Melbourne. VCAT vision is to render service to Victorians people in a fair,low cost and efficient way to help resolved disputes. Providing a low cost,accessible,efficient and independent tribunal who deliver a high quality resolution is the purpose of VCAT.Through the years,It has progress to take in new jurisdictions and functions under various acts,rules…

    • 1102 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Case Brief Case Name: Commonwealth v. Cheeks Citation: 423 Pa. 67, 223 A.2d 291 (1966) Vote: The Majority in Favor Author (Opinion of the Court): Justice Eagen Concurrences: None Dissent: Justice Cohen Facts: On October 11, 1963, Joe Henry Howell was stabbed and robbed by four young males on a public street in Philadelphia.…

    • 684 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    . The court ruled that the warrantless search of the dormitory room by the campus police violated the defendant's constitutional rights and that all evidence obtained as a result of the search should be suppressed in the case Commonwealth v. Eric W. Neilson, 423 Mass 75 (1996). College officials searched the room because they had reason to believe that there was an animal inside the room, which is against school policies. When they got in the room they proceeded to look in the closet; there they found a marijuana plant. The college officials immediately called the police and when they arrived they took pictures of the plant for evidence, and then with the help of the college officials, removed it from the room.…

    • 199 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    INTRODUCTION This essay examines the Australian court hierarchy, and the extension power the High Court attains as it has the ability too overturn decisions made by the Supreme Court. As it is the final court of appeal therefore reintegrates the point that the power of appointment is held within the body of the High Court. As the Australian Federal system consists of national court and a court system for each individual state and the two territories.…

    • 820 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Australian Legal System

    • 1683 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Legal systems can be dated back to the ancient peoples. There are many different legal systems that have evolved in other parts of the world. There are two types of legal system, the secular and religious legal system. It is argued that the Australian legal system is radically different to other legal systems. This, however, is not the case through findings and comparison with the Madayin legal system and Talmudic Jewish legal system.…

    • 1683 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In 1987, the Commonwealth and the States passed a legislation called the Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross vesting) Act 1987. The legislation was introduced to grant jurisdiction on the Family and Federal Courts and also on the Supreme Courts of other States to determine and hear issues involving State or Territorial law and also provide the transfer of proceedings between courts. In Australia, there is no national civil jurisdiction therefore the cross vesting scheme was developed in order to exercise a civil jurisdiction across all states. Cases such as Breavington v Godleman supported the idea that a plaintiff may sue in a court to enforce charges towards a wrong that is outside the territory of the court. However, the cross vesting scheme…

    • 218 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Mother Tongue Analysis

    • 531 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Language discrimination can be defined as the prejudical treatment against individuals who are unable to precisely get their message across as a result of what society views as "poor" or "limited" English. This is the reality for many people to whom english is a second language. Unfortunetly these individuals are disadvantaged by one of two things; their accent and/or non standard grammar. This is evident in Amy Tan's article Mother Tongue as well as Diane Eades Legal Recognitiong of Cultural Difference in Communication: The Case of Robyn Kina.…

    • 531 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Cultural Taboos Aboriginal

    • 1594 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Aborigines are particularly disadvantaged in our society. The problems and difficulties that they face when using the legal system are part of the reason for them being overrepresented in the criminal justice system. There are many issues which result in this participation; these include the presence of language barriers between an officer and an aboriginal suspect, cultural taboos aboriginal suspects suffer, their body language which tends to raise suspicion and their lack of understanding of the questioning procedure. These issues will be discussed to examine the topic at hand and suggested reforms will also be given to eliminate these complications to ensure that they receive a fair and unbiased hearing. Language barriers are the most common…

    • 1594 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    As Anthony (2013) has noted, the common law requires the judges to consider all alternative factors before sentencing. The judicial discretion would therefore be varied according to the situation and offender. In relation to indigenous people however, Anthony (2013) further indicates that indigenous factors are considered only “when the offender is a member of an Indigenous community and his/her offence or punishment reflects that membership” (p. 455). It implies the notion that indigenous people are not guaranteed special of lenient treatments based on who they are, but whether the offenses involved the indigenous communities. As the knowledge to why indigenous people are frequently engaged in the Criminal Justice System increases, the Australian government attempts to recognize indigeneity in the sentencing process.…

    • 1331 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In a criminal trial, a jury is a group usually comprised of twelve randomly chosen adults, whose role is to hear evidence, apply the law as directed by the judge, and then collectively decide if the defendant is guilty or not guilty of the crime they have been accused of, based only on the facts given. Juries have played a significant role in Australia’s justice system for quite some time, though in more recent years the role of juries has been reduced. In 2011, the NSW government changed the law so that accused persons could apply for judge alone trials and, with consent from the Director of Public, avoid juries entirely (Whitbourn 2013). Currently there is much debate as to whether or not the jury system should be scrapped entirely for criminal trials in NSW.…

    • 1003 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Indigenous Australians are grossly over-represented in the criminal justice system. However, the true extent of this over-representation differs between individual areas. Despite indigenous Australians only making up two per cent of the population, they accounted for over twenty seven per cent of the total prison population in 2014 (ABS). This high rate of imprisonment is not due to indigenous people being more likely to commit crime than other Australians, but rather indigenous Australians are over-represented due to a higher rate of offending and recidivism and also largely in part due to the fact that they have a lower rate of referrals to diversionary programs. This is largely due to the discriminatory practices by the police and the judicial…

    • 1204 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The overrepresentation of indigenous people is a substantial issue in our country that requires attention in order to maintain a positive relationship with the Aboriginals and remove any negative stigmatization against the indigenous culture (Welsh & Ogloff, 2008, pp. 492-494). This remains an issue in our society because there are increasing numbers of indigenous people in prison throughout the provinces due to systemic racism within the legal system, crimes committed due to socioeconomic challenges and cultural or language barriers (Fitzgerald & Carrington, 2008, pp. 524-525). Moreover, alternative courses of action should be addressed in order to decrease the overrepresentation of indigenous people in the criminal justice system.…

    • 888 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The purpose of this paper is to answer the case study questions and discuss the legal and ethical issues found in the case study Nepa vs. Commonwealth Department of Public Welfare. The case reveals elderly abuse by residents who endured abuse and neglect at the hands of the person charged with caring for them. It reviews the court’s findings of the petitioner’s appeal of the court’s judgment to revoke his license. This case study exemplifies types of patient and elderly abuse and patient rights violations which victims are often reluctant to report. “Patient abuse refers to the mistreatment or neglect of individuals in the health care setting” (Pozgar,2016, p. 418).…

    • 1301 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this, we are continually dismantling the cemented power dynamics that only exists to entrench itself further. Through the power of political theory, we no longer complicit in entrenching the power structures within generally…

    • 1402 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The ‘separation of powers’ is a doctrine that has caused much debate through the centuries, and although it is difficult to find its exact origins, it is possible to distinguish a basic separation of powers doctrine from the writings of Greek philosopher Aristotle. He remarked that a constitution must have three elements to be effective. The three are, first the deliberative, which discusses everything of common importance; second, the officials…; and third, the judicial element. The English political theorist, John Locke, conceived a similar idea about the different types of power.…

    • 1162 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays