Cognitive Dissonance In Skinner's Box

Improved Essays
Alleviating Cognitive Dissonance In the chapter “Quieting the Mind” of the book, Opening Skinner’s Box, author Lauren Slater examines the theory of cognitive dissonance. Leon Festinger, a psychologist at the University of Minnesota, originally introduced the theory of cognitive dissonance to psychology in 1957. The basic way of thinking about cognitive dissonance is that it refers to a situation when two or more cognitive elements (such as behaviors and attitudes/ beliefs) are inconsistent, causing psychological stress and discomfort. Festinger tested his theory by constructing several experiments to observe if participants changed their beliefs to be congruent with their behaviors. The results are that people have an inner drive to hold …show more content…
By changing their attitude or beliefs it creates a justification to their hypocrisy. For example the study Festinger observed about a cult who believed the earth would be destroyed by a flood experienced cognitive dissonance when the event failed to occur (Slater 115). Their beliefs became inconsistent. So they rationalized the circumstances in an attempt to justify their actions and beliefs. They indicated that the flood did not occur due to the cult spreading so much light that God saved the world from destruction. In other words they re-interpreted the evidence to conform their cognitive relation and keep mental harmony and make sense of what …show more content…
In other words, creating approved attitudes or beliefs that will coexist with the behavior. In an Undergraduate Research Journal, Shawn Gaulden, a sociologist major and student at the University of Central Florida, clearly identifies this method in his study. Gaulden’s research (as cited in Mahaffy, 1996), discovered that Christian lesbians resolved cognitive dissonance when their religious teachings contradicted their sexual identity (85). Christian lesbian’s defense mechanism to cognitive dissonance was to change their beliefs because it is nearly impossible to change the beliefs of the Christian community. So, they accommodate and harmonize their beliefs instead. They adopt the idea that Christianity accepts their sexual identity to synchronize with their behavior. Once again, pursuing that psychological stability that humans strongly desire for. These are great examples of how the human mind works to achieve self-conformity and cognitive

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Opening skinner box essay There are so many experiments in the world, but I will be focusing on one, Opening Skinner’s Box chapter #3. In this chapter eight volunteers agreed to an experiment to see what psychiatric wards are like on the inside. The view from the inside doesn’t always come out to what we think or expect it will be. It is discouraging on how people are treating in a psychiatric ward, but is there any hope for man kind? A psychiatric Dr. decides he wants to know if a mentally normal person goes into a ward if a psychiatrist would be able to tell weather he was or not mentally normal.…

    • 775 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “Varicella Vaccination Program Success” by Steven Novella, the author argues about the people who does not believe in vaccines and how are their arguments formulated. They ignore all the information and statitistics and focus on the smaller problems caused in the investigation, to assure that vaccines are not effective and riskful. However, besides all this, the author states at the end that we should follow more closely the vaccines programs and know that they are useful with the proper regulations. Moreover, Novella starts the article talking about the cognitive dissonance, which is “the state of mind that results when conflict arises between perceived reality and the cherished or learned facts, values, and beliefs regarding that reality.”,…

    • 398 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Cognitive dissonance explains the state of having inconsistent thoughts, beliefs, or attitudes. Psychologist Leon Festinger gave us a theory about how people are more likely to modify their beliefs in order to fit their behavior rather than to change their behavior to fit their beliefs. One of his experiment consisted of a group of people believing that the world was going to end on December 21st by a massive flood. Festinger’s prediction was that when the prophecy turned out to be false, a major effort to gain social support would happen and turned out to be true. He also performed another experiment where students were paid $1 and $20 to perform a boring task.…

    • 1468 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The presence of danger or irritability plays a huge impact on the reactions of every individual. According to Stanley Milgram in his novel the “The Perils of Obedience”, he states that authority figures can cause signs of tension and turn people into “lethal intrustuments in the hands of unscrupulous authority” (184). Also in Chapter 4 of Lauren Slaters novel, “Obedience Skinners Box”, states that humans rely on their social cues and see what others to do in reaction to someone in danger by using Darley and Latane’s Training Manual- Five Stage Approach that connects with a murder that took place in New York. Cruelty is a characteristic that every individual has whether it is caused intentionally or unintentionally.…

    • 1327 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Cognitive dissonance theory is the theory that states that an individual attitudes and actions do not match each other. It is the tendency for an individual to seek balance among our cognition (beliefs, opinions, etc) when there is a discomfort or a buffer (dissonance/inconsistency) between our attitude and our action. To solve this problem, he or she may change something to eliminate or reduce the dissonance. Attitude is the way we feel about a particular way towards an object, people, and events. A real life example is when I was in high school…

    • 213 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Opening Skinner’s Box: Obscura Having test subjects perform potentially damaging experiments on other test subjects is immoral and unethical. How would you feel if in this class we ran unexplained, undetailed experiments on each student in the class for a grade and to test how obedient each student is? In Opening Skinner’s Box: Obscura, such an experiment takes place where you were forced into a corner. Mentally you were cornered and had no choice but to cooperate with the experiment. Your mind is telling you that what you’re doing is wrong but you keep going because the guy in the white lab coat tells you to finish.…

    • 828 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Default Mode Networks

    • 672 Words
    • 3 Pages

    When discussing political topics, most people cannot be persuaded to change their mind. They are firmly rooted in their beliefs and in a way, the beliefs make people who they are (Resnick). A psychologist who works for the University of Southern California set out to determine why our brains receive conflicting beliefs as personal attacks. The psychologist, Jonas Kaplan, concluded that the default mode network is triggered to a greater degree when presented with an opposing political belief versus when presented with conflicting mundane facts (Resnick).…

    • 672 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The LBGT Community

    • 559 Words
    • 3 Pages

    They identify with the base in Maslow's pyramid of needs, and that is the "physiological needs" just like the rest of us. Due to the idea that these sexual orientations are not blended naturally into society, this community has found that it does not identify with the rest of the pyramid. Historically, same sex activity was embraced by the Romans in the public bathrooms that they had. This changed with the insertion of religion where mentality has changed over the issue of sexual orientation. It has become a burden to society, even heterosexual activity was considered a burden if it wasn't consummated after the holy church performs its marriage rituals first.…

    • 559 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The findings in this study strongly supported Festinger’s (1957) theory of cognitive dissonance and derivations in relation to forced compliance (Festinger and Carlsmith 1957). An obvious strength of this piece of research is the importance of the theory to the field of psychology. Cognitive Dissonance theory is one of the most extensively studied theories in social psychology and is considered one of the most influential theories in the field. (Gabronski 2012, Perlovsky 2013,…

    • 682 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the Cognitive Dissonance Experiment conducted by Leon Festinger, the researchers were interested in how we rationalize to ourselves about why we think and behave certain ways. Participants were students enrolled in a certain course at Stanford University. Based off of this factor and the time period, we can assume that they were mostly of similar background (white and middle class). Once in the lab, they were told that the experiment was about how expectations affect the experience of something. There were 2 groups in every round of the experiment.…

    • 679 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Almost anyone with television or Internet access can report feeling irritated by negative political advertisements. Although the targets are different, all negative ads aim to dissuade citizens from voting for a certain candidate by presenting negative information on him or her. The information may be factual, such as controversial policies they enacted, or closer in nature to high school gossip. Many argue that although messages of fear and negativity are persuasive, negativity can also decrease participation. Krupnikov (2011) found that negativity demobilizes voters when they have already selected a preferred candidate and the negativity targets their preferred candidate.…

    • 1189 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A typical example of cognitive dissonance; for example have the habit to enjoy playing with venomous snake, but you know that the snake venom is very harmful then that would result in cognitive dissonance. It is reasonable that cognitive dissonance extend to include justification of effort as a product of cognitive dissonance. When an individual is trapped between two beliefs or behaviors, or even attitude, the level of the conflict could be strong at the point that it creates discomfort or loss of harmony within the individual’s life style. Regardless of the awareness whether positive or negative, individual would engage the ambition of taking the risk to defend his beliefs. “The magnitude of dissonance depends on importance or value of the elements (e.g. knowledge, belief, attitudes) that are dissonant” (Metin & Camgoz,…

    • 461 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Hysteria As Demonstrated In The Crucible And 1950’s America In 1950’s America the war on communism had reached a high point and anti-communist feelings were overwhelmingly common. In response to the anti-communist hysteria occurring around him, Arthur Miller, a well known playwright, wrote The Crucible to demonstrate the hysteria surrounding the American citizens and their government. By analyzing the usage of the causes of hysteria and individual rationalization of actions that are commonplace in The Crucible, a reader can see how hysteria starts in a society and what prevents and keeps hysteria from occurring.…

    • 1142 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Noam Chomsky criticizes B.F. Skinner’s model for verbal behavior. Chomsky thinks that Skinner overreaches as he applies his model for non-human operant behavior to human linguistic behavior, because Skinner extrapolated his model for the former from controlled experimental settings while the latter exists in much more complex situations. Simply, Chomsky thinks that Skinner’s model for verbal behavior is unscientific, and therefore unusable either as an explanation for verbal behavior or as a basis to build further knowledge. For Chomsky, Skinner’s model only addresses the most superficial aspects of verbal behavior, wrongly conflates artificial environments with naturally occurring ones and terms from experimental psychology with their homonyms from popular…

    • 783 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This produces a feeling of discomfort which leads to an adjustment in an attitude, belief or behavior to reduce the uneasiness the person may have and restore internal peace. Rumor transmission is linked to cognitive dissonance due to the relationship that deals with belief. If a person does not believe in a rumor, they will most likely not transmit it; the rumor does not produce high anxiety. Rumors that are “wedge-driving” fall into play with cognitive dissonance. People who associate themselves with groups that are criticized and denounced tend to feel threatened.…

    • 1292 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays