Case Study: Confronting An Ethical Dilemma

Great Essays
Confronting an Ethical Dilemma As humans we make many decisions on a day to day basis. Many times these decisions can be made rather easily as the choice is clear. However, when faced with an ethical dilemmas, the outcomes have both short-term and long-term consequences. Unfortunately, these dilemmas are situations in which there might not be a right solution no matter the decision. When faced with an ethical dilemma, Blanchard & Peale, authors of The Power of Ethical Management, suggest that an individual ask themselves three relevant questions to help guide them in making the best decision. The first question is: Is it legal? Then, Is it balanced? And finally, How will it make me feel about myself? (Rasberry, 1988).
Relevant Ethical Principles In the particular scenario,a young couple has a newborn with multiple anomalies and deformities and decides against any life-sustaining medical interventions. One of the main principle in making decisions about one’s health is autonomy. (Parsapoor, A., Parsapoor, M.-B., Rezaei, N., & Asghari, F. (2014). In this
…show more content…
In addition, parents who receive options from their doctors are subject to the view, values, and practice style who might be pursued differently. A healthcare team could include or disclude relevant facts or information in hopes of persuading the parents to chose their recommendation and doctors may not consider all viable options for the child unless they are convinced that the options were appropriate (Behrman & Butler, 2007). Another argument that opposes the parents’ decision against using any life sustaining technologies would be that there is no way to know or predict the future. Their child might be able to lead a normal life without suffering or

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    In the case stated, there are several possible ethical dilemmas. The ethical dilemmas that are relating to this case consist of, Hiding or divulging information, taking an unfair advantage, giving or allowing false impressions, condoning false impressions, balancing ethical dilemmas, and buying influence. The manufacturers of the “infant baby walker” stated that at the age of four months a baby would be able to indulge in upright movements, well before their cognitive skills will allow them to do so on there own. This brings the first ethical dilemma “hiding or divulging information.…

    • 1385 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Upon asking all the guest speaker how they deal with their vales and ethical dilemmas in human services. Some said it was hard while other said it took them some time to keep their professional and personal opinions to them self. Being a social worker is not easy because it takes a value of self- determination but it could be influenced by family, friends, school, church , the workplace and off-course how can we forget our social class, ethnicity and gender. In chapter five Values and Ethical Dilemmas there is a section that talks about can workers be completely unbiased?…

    • 371 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Such decisions regarding patients with severe and deteriorating illness should be processed with respect to the patient’s condition becoming worse with time. Having an ethics board or a medical community to alleviate the pressure of a single doctor making a decision for a patient who is not able to act autonomously would allow for a treatment plan to be determined earlier. In Mary’s case, the court ruling prevented the doctor’s from acting to save her…

    • 815 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    While reading about " Paternalism and Respect for Patient Autonomy", what stuck out the most to me was example about a Jehovah's Witness who was in need of a blood transfusion or else they would not survive (pg 59,60). With that issue still standing out in my thoughts, I continued to read. Then I came across another proposal in this section about making dissions for a patient who does not have the ability to make the same chooses he or she would normally choose. Continuing on to the other sections, this scenario came about: A young 16 year old girl is rushed into the emergency room by her parents. She complains of cramps in her mid sections.…

    • 230 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    A person (caregiver), such as Mr. David Greene may think that it’s valuable that people decide about other people lives, rather than the love ones is their midst get better, versus the consequence of the patient having the option to decide about their own health. People that are competent to make decisions (Kleinlugtenbelt, Molewijk, & Widdershoven, 2011). According to the article, ROLE OF EMOTIONS IN MORAL CASE DELIBERATION: THEORY, PRACTICE, AND METHODOLOGY (2011), stated policies based on a control-related autonomy ideal should be reasonable, because to interfere with patients’ decisions, even regarding those individuals that base their information obtained. In most instances, retaining a patients’ information upon their decisions, probably best for the interest of the client in order to restrict from doing less harm, than good (Kleinlugtenbelt, Molewijk, & Widdershoven, 2011).…

    • 1776 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Ethical Dilemmas Essay I have chosen to analyze case two and this paper will outline my understanding, exploration, and final decision-making process as it applies to the ethical dilemmas presented. Understanding the Dilemmas This case has a variety of ethical dilemmas occurring across several contexts (personal, societal, and organizational). Reflecting on the theories and conceptual models presented in this course, I found the Five Faces of Oppression (Young, 2014) and the Ecological Systems Theory (Bronfenbrenner, 1979) helpful in conceptualizing these various circumstances and contexts.…

    • 1501 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    1. Rachels article, talks about an incident where a baby has an intestinal blockage and needs surgery to live or the parents may choose to let the baby die. In this incident, the parents choose to let the baby die rather than try to save the child. Rachels believes that it is morally wrong of the parents to not try to save their child through surgical methods and just focus on the Down syndrome. The parents believe that since the child will suffer in life, as will they, then why let the child live.…

    • 501 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    A conflict between a physician and patient on the course of treatment is a common topic that arises in bioethical conversation. This case explores the topic of paternalistic choices dealing with patient autonomy and when it is ethically reasonable for a physician to intervene and decide as to whether an individual is competent to make decisions about their own care. The patient in the case, Mr. Howe was asked to make a lifesaving medical decision while in duress and not fully understanding the procedure and the potential outcome if he refused. In this case I believe the physician made the correct decision to intubate Mr. Howe against his explicit instructions not to. The physician made a determination that the patient was not accurately expressing his wishes as if he was of sound mind.…

    • 834 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    The worst case for people in their life is when they lose decision-making capacity for themselves. Many fears that their choices will be taken away at the end of their lives. People are afraid not only of sickness and death, but of the possibility that extra suffering will be forced on them. In such cases, advance directives can help the patient and healthcare providers make decisions with no ethical issues. According to the Standards for decisions when patients lack decision-making capacity article, advance directives are statements made by the patient when they could make proper decisions which indicates who should be their surrogate or what kind of interventions are accepted when they lose their decision-making capacity (Lo, 2000).…

    • 337 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Agree that in any ethical dilemma scenario one’s personal, professional, and social values are tested. And the established known qualities of these values are affected. A common practice…

    • 211 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    Introduction and definition of key words A dilemma arises in a situation that requires a choice by an individual, between two contrasting options, which choice is difficult to make due to a conflict within the individual’s cognitive processes on what to do (Cambridge Dictionary, 2016). Hence, ethical dilemmas will always arise when the conflict at hand is based on moral principles that govern an individual’s behaviour i.e. choosing what would the right thing (doing good) or the wrong thing (causing harm) to do is in the present situation (Paul & Elder, 2006). Karen’s three “elements for existence of an ethical dilemma” are (Karen , 2012); i. An individual (the “agent”) is presented with a situation requiring the best possible course of action.…

    • 1665 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is a simple fact of life that at some point in our lives, we will be faced with a moral dilemma. These situations arise due to the fact that as professionals, we are bombarded with the ethical standards and principles of different stakeholders. We all develop a personal moral code, but what are we to do when this code differs from the code of our employer? The code our customers/clients? The law?…

    • 821 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The philosophical problem surrounding medical paternalism is that it is considered morally unacceptable for a physician to veto one’s autonomy and act paternalistically by intentionally lying, providing false information, or withholding information. By acting in this way, the physician is limiting the patients’ ability to make a completely autonomous decision for themselves. This allows for the question “is medical paternalism ever justified”? In this paper, I will argue in support of Zembaty’s thesis that medical paternalism may be justified if acting non-paternalistically would potentially destroy the patient’s autonomy. For the purpose of this paper, medical paternalism will refer to a physician interfering with a patient’s autonomy with…

    • 220 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the last several years, the physician-patient relationship has shifted dramatically from a less Hippocratic based paternalistic approach, to that of a relationship centered on respect for patient autonomy; this new approach integrated informed consent and shared decision making. Autonomy remains a much debated, but central idea in both western medicine and medical ethics. Autonomy for our purposes in medical ethics, can be defined as the right of competent adults to make informed decisions about their medical care. The debate ultimately surrounds what role patient autonomy should play in medicine. Some believe that patients should be seen as fully autonomous persons, as they know better than anyone else what is good or bad for them.…

    • 1231 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Despite what many might think, a patient 's right to refuse medical treatment has a very important meaning in the lives of many. People who have medical complications must learn to work with doctors and or surgeons in hospitals. With having the right to refuse medical treatment patients feel as if they have more power over their own health and future. Even though surgeons are qualified in making medical treatment decisions, patients should have the right to refuse medical treatment options. Patients should have the right to consider all medical options based on risk factors, success and effectiveness, and their living-will.…

    • 1112 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays