Analysis Of Mini-Sombreros, By Catherine Rampell

Superior Essays
In her recent work, "Political Correctness devours yet another College, fighting over mini-sombreros" Catherine Rampell depicts two students being impeached for celebrating their Latino friend's birthday by wearing mini-sombreros to socially act like a Mexican can be offensive to other Mexicans and to Bowdoin College. I've always believed that people who culturally appropriate their culture to another are not human decency. For instance, the fact that the tequila themed partygoers dressed like Mexicans of the Mexican culture as funny or to mock that culture is culturally inappropriate. In Rampell's view, this act is known as, "cultural appropriation" (pg 2). Rampell agrees when she writes, "Bowdoin students that were Americans created …show more content…
For instance, borrowing ideas from the Mexican culture such as the two students carefully dressing in the clothing, arts, artifacts is in itself not problematic. The problem was that the other guests borrowed ideas from the Mexican culture such as carefully dressing in the clothing, arts, artifacts and took pictures. After taking pictures, they posted them on social media that was problematic. Rampell agrees when she writes, "Pictures of guest wearing mini-sombreros showed up on social media, the administrators went crazy. They sent schoolwide emails to the students notifying their reaction that wearing mini-sombreros and posting pictures of wearing that clothing could be a possible act of stereotyping the Mexican culture and it's people. Although the administrators are right to be upset about the other guests dressing up as a stereotype of the Mexican culture because the Latinos and Mexicans can be offended by the idea and it should never be a costume or the ending of a joke. But the administration exaggerates when they claim that the two students of dressing up as a stereotype of the Mexican culture. To put it in another way, today and forever has been the 21st century. in addition, 21st century "cultural appropriation"-like globalization-isn't just inevitable, it's potentially positive. The administrators need to stop guarding cultures and subcultures in an effort to preserve them not adopt one and condemn another. In other words, they need to not adopt the Soviet culture and condemn the two students multi-cultural society. It's naive, paternalistic, and counterproductive. The students' multicultural society subculture tradition and custom to exchange ideas, and styles are one of their tenets and joys of their culture. To put it another way, the administrators could have moved past the blaming and punishing, and co-exist in a way that's both creatively

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Deena Prichep’s “A Campus More Colorful Than Reality: Beware That College Brochure”(National Public Radio’s Weekend Edition, December 29, 2013) is a small article that shines light on a problem dealing with how College brochures target and sell diversity to attract more students, to seem more diverse and most importantly “miss the mark” on diversity. Prichep talks about how a picture of an African American student by the name of Diallo Shabazz was photoshopped on the cover of an Admissions booklet. “Shabazz remembered seeing a cover shot of students at a football game. But he’d never been to a football game” said Prichep when interviewing Shabazz. The article focuses on whether or not this action taken by hundred of colleges, not only this…

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Chameleon Case Study

    • 317 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The opening scene in the Chameleon a case study by John Gray and Associates takes place at a school board meeting. Residents from across the community materialized in record numbers to discuss the issue of bilingual education at the local high school. Recently, at school, some students labeled a few teachers and administrators as prejudicial and supporters of discriminatory practices when Mexican American's and Vietnamese students were not tabbed to participate on the cheerleader team. As a result, the climate of the school transitioned into a negative atmosphere of anarchy, disarray, and hostility.…

    • 317 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    At the Oscars, commentators suspected that Zendaya “probably smells like weed or patchouli oil” (Fragoso). The accusations that because she is African American and wearing dreadlocks means she does weed is appropriating negative connotation to a culture. Furthermore, the assumption is proven false because not only African tribes but “Hinduism, Christianity, Judaism, [and] Greeks” (Fragoso), have appeared with dreadlocks throughout history. Again, Fragoso reiterates that you in fact appropriate an exclusive part of within one culture. To conclude her argument using induction and stereotypes, she generalizes that although there have been countless incidences to learn from “we still haven’t seemed to reach a conclusion as a population” (Fragoso).…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    1. What were the goals of the Indian boarding schools? Indian boarding schools were the brain child of Captain Richard Henry Pratt. After his experiment on immersing Plains Indian prisoners of war in the white culture, he believed the best way to “solve” the “Indian problem” was to brainwash the children. By isolating and “deprograming” the Native American children, the American government could break up the tribal mentality of the next generation.…

    • 481 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Garcia states “We are exposed to the ways of life of different peoples, it is inevitable that new influences will seep in and mix with what’s established”. In other words, Garcia says that we can not hid from the fact that all people sometime in their life will want or will change their culture perspective. In other recent research author Crispin Sartwell of the Los Angeles Times pin points other key facts to this in the article We Can’t Let the Culture Scolds Win. Crispin talks about how in today’s society people see culture appropriation is ‘making fun’ of other culture and the traits of different people. Crispin insist “when…

    • 786 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is nearly impossible for pastors to be familiar with every culture that exists out there, in the world. People will come from different countries, states or even counties that may have a radically different culture than the pastor. Andy Crouch, in his book Culture Making, argues that: Culture is more than an ideology, trends, fads, fashion, sense of ethnic identity, the collections of practices, beliefs and stories that carve out a sense of distinctiveness and pride or failure and shame. It’s more than governing ideas, values and presuppositions of our society—as it is used in phrases like “culture wars,” ”the culture disbelief” or “the decline of our culture.”…

    • 607 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Cultural Appropriation

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Appreciation or Appropriation? Have you ever stopped to think about Halloween costumes? Dressing up as a Latino or a Native American is considered normal in our society. However, these cultures aren’t meant to be costumes.…

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    It’s fascinating how people have been able to make so many different definitions for the word culture; a word that was thought to have one singular definition. People of all cultures are unique not just in their methods and ways of life, but also in their definitions of culture. One person can describe culture as something that can bring family and a community together, but another person may define it as the exact opposite; something that tears people apart and in turn will rip apart a community. Neither of them are wrong or right however, because culture is something that is tangible. Culture is something that changes with time instead of against it.…

    • 1377 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Infantilizing College College campuses across the U.S. have initiated change, and it’s not the tuition and costs of textbooks, it’s the elimination of anything considered controversial from classrooms and curriculum. A shift is being made to rid college campuses of offensive, racial, or sexist material and topics. In the September 2015 issue of The Atlantic, authors Greg Lukianoff and Jonathan Haidt poignantly title their article “The Coddling of the American Mind” and investigate why U.S. college students are demanding censorship in their studies and “trigger warnings” on the syllabus’ (Lukianoff and Haidt). A crusade is taking place across college campuses everywhere to rid subject matter and discussions of issues that may be regarded as…

    • 1094 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The novel The Tortilla Curtain, written by author T. C. Boyle, gives us a telescope view into two different worlds of culture, highlighting the differences between the upper-middle and lower class in southern California. The book breaks into three different sections that contain eight chapters that deals with numerous parallels that connect the lifestyles of the characters, but also contrast them. The author tends to switch back and forth between each chapter in order for us to understand the two main characters the Rincóns and the Mossbachers. The first part of the book called “Arroyo Blanco,” opens up with a descriptive but haunting event that occurs the afternoon as one of the main character’s name of Delaney Mossbacher is driving near the…

    • 2277 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I want to attend TASS to improve my social and writing skills, further my knowledge of African American culture and be able to incorporate it to my everyday life. Learning about another ethnicity 's history and background will provide insight and aid me in understanding the differences and similarities between us. With this knowledge, I will form a strong intelligent opinion all while being able to present the necessary evidence in order to support it. I am not only of East Asian descent, but also female. In this society, I am considered an ethnic minority but I will not let this hinder nor undermine my abilities or potential.…

    • 1216 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Amandla Stenberg, a young actress and social justice activist, stated in a recently uploaded YouTube video, “What if America loved Black people as much as they loved Black culture?” , she was referencing a deep rooted issue that lately has been a key concern within racism in America. Cultural appropriation is the adoption or “borrowing” elements of one culture by a member of another culture. Cultural appropriation is a form of internal racism that may or may not be in an intentionally negative light. The line between appropriation and appreciation is very thin, though it is clear when said line has been crossed.…

    • 1577 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    What is Cultural appropriation? Cultural appropriation: is a sociological concept which views the adoption or use of elements of one culture by members of a different culture as a largely negative phenomenon. It has become normalized in media to take specific components from different cultures and weave it into “trends” while downplaying the significance of those same components to their cultures. While cultural appropriation seems harmless to those who do it, it is demoralizing to those societies, people need to be aware of the ignorance that they are demonstrating by picking and choosing what they consider to be the “cool” aspects of a culture. Cultural appropriation is a topic that is currently highly debated and criticized.…

    • 1366 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    "Cultural Appropriation” mean Choosing any effort of intellectual, cultural, artistic or believe, individually or collectively from other cultures and make it as a special effort an unlawful or immoral manner. Illegal Quote intellectual effort extended to ancient history, it is still going on by individuals or institutions, or even political systems. Multiple purposes, known on a personal level, change the culture of minorities by political systems, and change the culture of a society by the occupation to control resources. Stand against this behavior depends on the three parties, artist, producer, and the audience Support sentences: Concluded sentences: The responsibility is belonged to artistes, producers, and audience. Surly, Theft of intellectual effort, culture, and the arts became popular for a long time during the occupation of European countries for many Third World countries.…

    • 1223 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    We can all admit that at one point in life we have caught ourselves following the latest trends. We assume the style is an idea that is in for the moment, that came randomly from someone or somewhere that does not concern us. When in actuality it derived from a culture far from where we are with a deeper and significant meaning. This is what is known as cultural appropriation. No matter if it is an accident or intentional, taking an idea or style that does not belong to our original culture is considered as cultural appropriation.…

    • 1084 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays