Arguments Against Genetic Discrimination

Superior Essays
People are worried about being rejected for a job, because of their genetic information. No company should have the right to hire, fire or judge people based on their genetic background. Genetic discrimination is when people are treated unfairly because of the differences in their DNA and their chance of getting a disease. A number of laws have passed that have protected people under the law. For example, GINA, which protects people from genetic discrimination from employers and health insurance providers. Even though laws have been passed to help protect people from genetic discrimination, companies have broken the law, paid a penalty and were free to go. The laws that are too be passed must be hard on the employer and act as some kind of …show more content…
Also the company threatened to terminate a contract of one worker who refused to get himself tested. This shows that companies violated the law and that there should be stricter laws than just paying the penalty. This wasn’t the only case linked to genetic discrimination; other cases have been reported where the insurance companies have stopped covering healthcare for patients because they were diagnosed with a genetic disease. The council for responsible genetics wrote “Seven-year-old Danny is in perfect health, but a genetic tests reveals that he has a gene predisposing him to a heart disorder. Even though he takes medication that lowers his risk of a heart attack, he is denied health insurance. His insurance company argues that since his gene has been present since birth, this qualifies as a pre-existing medical condition.” Another case reported by the council of responsible genetics was “Kim is a social worker with a large human services agency. During a staff workshop on caring for people with chronic illnesses, Kim mentions that she was the primary caretaker for her mother who died of Huntington’s disease. Kim herself has a 50% chance of developing this fatal genetic condition. One week …show more content…
The verge stated “What’s even more striking, however, is that 30 percent of participants said that they became more worried about genetic discrimination after reading about GINA.” Which means that people were actually worried that this is becoming a problem. The US government needs to educate its people on the rights of its people and how they can get justice. People are afraid to get genetically tested and have that data listed on their medical record because they think, that it might affect their career and that will judge them. GINA does not cover life insurance, so that means that people can be refused a policy, if the company requests a genetic testing to be done. However, at this rate of advancements in the science industry, “genetic discrimination” might not exist, because every treatment will be gene based and there is a chance that none of us will have mutated genes. However, the government needs to find a way to reassure the

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    Ross L. Jones’s article investigates a society that practiced eugenics during the last two centuries. Eugenics was a major school of thought based on science and accepted as true by upper-class people (165). Eugenics played an enormous role in Australian society by denouncing those who had “inferior genes”, which was approved by the medical community and the politicians of that era. The main motivator for eugenics was the educated class and politicians. Pro-eugenicists sought the “maximising of an individual’s potential” as long as the individual represented people they believed were like themselves and stripped those who were seen as “inferior” of their rights as human beings and citizens (166).…

    • 395 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Yet it is also warned against as, depending on state privacy laws, the results of genetic testing may be shared with insurance. If a disease is considered pre-existing due to genetic variances, insurance coverage may lessen (U.S. National Library of Medicine, 2017) Yet without genetic testing, diagnosis for even the most trained physicians becomes difficult. For some subdivisions of…

    • 998 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Medical professionals are required for all genetic testing, because they are the only ones that can give provide a comprehensive understanding of the raw testing results. Because Direct-To-Consumer (DTC) genetic testing companies are relatively new, the government has not set thorough regulations on them, allowing room for some companies to faulty methods and make false claims without providing sufficient evidence. On the other hand, licensed physicians have a fiduciary obligation to use their extensive knowledge to give accurate results and explanations for the benefit of their patients. Also, licensed physicians can accurately interpret genetic testing results, explaining to the patient how much at risk they are of certain diseases while…

    • 271 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When the a passage from the legislation express about protecting genetic information led to an inaccurate message to the public that genetic information is extremely important than other medical information but in reality all type of genetic or medical information is important it should be kept privately. Even when legislation on protecting genetic privacy has been introduced to the Congress but it still has not been passed. Only a few states have passed but it still early to tell how effective it’s. 5 There are many laws that were pass to protect a person genome such as “Common Rule” in 1991 that required all federal funded research projects to obtain a necessary informed consent of the participant and unlike the case of Henrietta the participant must understand the risk of releasing their private information. GINA in 2008 and HIPAA in 1996 that maintain patient individually identifiable health information, there also certificates of confidentiality that was issues by National Institutes of Health (N.I.H) that protect the privacy of research participants against investigators and institutions from disclose any information from any civil, criminal, and federal, state, and local level.…

    • 1562 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Gattac Designer Babies

    • 891 Words
    • 4 Pages

    It would not be fair if employers and insurance companies to get our genetic information. It builds a biased opinion as soon as they attain this information. If one employee has a high amount of training and is qualified then that person will get denied to a person with good DNA even if the person with the good DNA is not qualified as much as the other employee. In GATTACA Vincent applied to GATTACA in which he was denied work because of his genetic information but when he got in he was achieving work no one else there was achieving. Thats shows that work and other organizations should not get our genetic information because it would be unfair to those that are more qualified than those with good genes.…

    • 891 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    I am very aware of the popular belief out there that, we live in a time of sharply decreasing faith in the criminal justice system. The historic mistreatment of African-Americans at the hands of the criminal justice system is widely acknowledged, and no one would agree that the vestiges of those tragic practices have all been removed. But no doubt in my mind that progress has been recorded. Americans have tried to address these problems over the years by requiring objective, race-neutral justifications for government actions within the criminal justice system. We have, for example, required that the jury representation be composed of a fair cross-section of the community.…

    • 377 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Race and ethnicity has little effect of genetic makeup, but it has a great effect on the level of care that an individual receives. There are many studies indicating that minority groups receive more expensive and lower quality health care. Some studies take a look at whether the site of care affects the quality of care among minority groups and how different lifestyle factors could also influence health. Using race in the health care system creates unnecessary discrimination. This discrimination leads to adverse health effects for minority populations.…

    • 1461 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many are worried about their information getting out to health insurance companies or even employers, but have a reason to be reassured about the concept of gene mapping. “The Genetic Information Non-Discrimination Act (GINA) prohibits the use of genetic information by health insurance companies for determining a person’s eligibility for insurance or determining insurance premiums” (U.S. News). GINA also prohibits the use of genetic information by employers. With GINA the public can be confident about mapping their genes and knowing it won’t be used against them in any way…

    • 980 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    (EEOC, DATE) The American’s with Disabilities Act of 1990 has given individuals with disabilities the protection they need in order to get the treatment they deserve. The Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act of 2008 “is a federal law that protects individuals from genetic discrimination in health insurance and employment. Genetic discrimination is the misuse of genetic information.”…

    • 1086 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The existence of race is a matter of contention. Forensic anthropologists deem it a useful entity in their line of work due to finding success with using race for matching skeletal remains with a particular profile. However, arguments against the existence of a biological race are convincing. Analysis of genetic sequences has revealed that whilst there is much individual genetic variation, between population differences are minute (Livingstone and Dobzhansky, 1962). Specifically, Templeton (1998) analysed mitochondrial DNA, finding 85% of variation was due to ‘individual differences’ whilst only 15% could be put down to differences between race.…

    • 871 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The issue though, with this is the expansion of genetic testing from diseases that can be treated to diseases where there is nothing to be done (Timmermans). In the past. many diseases could be treatable - which provides a reason for the testing. “Screening for phenylketonuria, for example, has meant that newborns affected by the condition can be placed on a special diet in the first days of life, thereby preventing mental retardation” (Timmermans). But, major testing companies are now pushing to expand the tests to untreatable diseases - which has no positive effects unless women plan to abort.…

    • 1060 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Prenatal genetic sequencing is a scientific procedure that predicts the risk of developing an illness later in life, and/or shows potential traits such as athleticism and intelligence in an unborn child. These predictions of illness and potential traits come from analyzing fetal DNA found in a sample of the mother’s blood. A very important and main concern for prenatal genetic testing is for preparation of treatment for a predicted illness in a child. Also parents are often interested in these predictions simply for having an indication of what they are getting themselves into. Prenatal genetic testing is a rising topic in present ethical conflicts.…

    • 2208 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Founders Pavilion, Inc. (2014), the defendant required employees and new applicants to provide family medical history, refused to accommodate an individual with disability resulting in early termination, and refused to hire and terminated women because they were pregnant. Further the organization failed to post the federal law requirements about equal opportunity employment. Founders was found to have violated the equal opportunity laws including GINA, and had to pay substantial monetary pay outs to those affected by the discrimination, have continuous monitoring and training with the EEOC, and adopt policies regarding equal opportunity laws (EEOC v. Founders Pavilion Inc.). Your discussion brought to light the serious implications of not obeying GINA, and the rights employees have if they feel they have discriminated against, wrongfully terminated, or harassed due to their own or a relative’s genetic…

    • 408 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Throughout history, racial inequality has been a recurring issue. Three leaders have publicly addressed this issue, and we have all heard or read their speeches. The question is, who had the strongest arguments? Well, it was none other than Martin Luther King himself. He had the most solid cases compared to Clinton and Bush.…

    • 790 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Genetic testing can help fix many complications such as: finding genetic abnormalities and helping couples through in vitro fertilization. Genetic testing is very beneficial for many people; however, the majority of people will use it during pregnancy or when thinking about conceiving a child. Everyone that does genetic testing volunteers because all types of testing are voluntary (“What is genetic… reference.”). Before a person is tested they should make sure that they have as much of their medical history known…

    • 1183 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays