Top Dog The Science Of Winning And Losing Analysis

Improved Essays
“Johnny, you have to come upstairs to see my room!” Daniel shouted, with a smile spread across his face. Daniel was nine years old and had started playing community sports once he turned five. He played four seasons a year – soccer, basketball, lacrosse, and baseball – and received a participation trophy at the end of each season. That meant there were almost twenty trophies in his room! Not to mention the extra few he had snuck out of his brothers’!
Johnny bounded up the stairs, as fast as his little body could handle, excited to see what Daniel had to show him! As soon as he set foot in the doorway, his mouth fell open in awe. “OH MY GOSH!” he shouted, “so many trophies!” Downstairs, Daniel’s mom heard the shout and sheepishly apologized to Johnny’s mom for the ruckus. “This always happens when Danny shows his guests all of his trophies,” she said biting back a grin. “He’s just an amazing athlete!” Years later, Daniel wondered what happened. He made his middle school
…show more content…
Ashely Merryman, co-author of “Top Dog: The Science of Winning and Losing” did a study on children whose received lots of participation awards and discovered that those children were more likely to develop narcissistic traits, acting more superior and entitled like Johnny. Not only do these millennial children become self-absorbed, but there is a chain of other qualities and attitudes that result in kids being unable to become independent and these qualities stay with them and hurt them for the rest of their lives. For example, Susan Haines, Licensed Medical Counselor and Talani Torres, experienced Dance Teacher did research together to test how millennials that grew up in the “trophy culture” were impacted. They found overwhelming results to support that Children are raised to think that they are the best and when they find out they aren’t they go into shock. One of the older dance students

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    What would life be like if everyone got an award for simply showing up to work, school, and sports? Based on the "Trophies for All" policy every youth athlete gets a trophy for simply coming to games and practices. Participation trophies do not prepare these future adults to live and work in the real world. These youth athletes also need to know that you have to work hard to get what you want. And finally, youth athletes need to know that not everyone is a winner.…

    • 645 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    “Children Need to Play, not Compete” present a compelling argument, that children need to have fun playing sports rather than just focusing on winning. The text, written by Jessica Statsky is an impressive piece of work. Pathos, ethos, logos and kairos all come together perfectly to support the claim and the evidence to back it is also strong. Right off the bat the author has pathos appeal, “And though many adults regard Little League baseball and Peewee Football as a basic part of childhood, the games are not always joyous ones”.…

    • 163 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    On the topic of participation awards, Lisa Heffernan and Vivian Diller have both published articles advocating either for, or against rewarding children at a young age, regardless if they’ve won a game or not. In terms of making a strong argument, both writers used celebrity testimonies, life experience, and quotes from reputable sources, some tactics more effective than others. In Lisa Heffernan’s article favoring participation trophies, “In Defense of Participation Trophies: Why They Really do Teach the Right Values,” she often pulls from her most powerful and relevant source to her topic- her son. Statements such as “When my son was around eight years old … he scoffed at the very idea that such an award existed.” would play a critical role in setting up a counter argument, but much like her other quotations in her article, it was followed by a statement from Hillary L. Friedman, a sociologist, that initially seems to back up her son’s opinion.…

    • 477 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Corey Turner remembers collecting participation trophies from the YMCA soccer program he was involved in as a young athlete. These trophies are now sitting in a dusty box somewhere in his parent's basement. This leads him to question whether or not young athletes should receive trophies for just showing up. Corey Turner is not alone, people across the nation have debated this issue for as long as youth sports have been in existence. I believe that kids should not get trophies for participating because kids should learn life lessons from both wins and losses and participation trophies do more harm than good.…

    • 473 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many people find themselves asking if participation trophies are even important or not, or if we should even have them in general. Well we should, for reasons that might have been overlooked. Participation trophies show a great significance consisting of commitment and dedication, they remind one of an experience or the friendships they made, and they give more meaning than you would think to a young child learning self-confidence. Commitment and and dedication show the growth of responsibility and a participation trophy shows just this. Richard Greenberg says this, “Participation trophies mark the fact that these kids kept a commitment and showed up to the games.”…

    • 490 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Participation Trophys

    • 350 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In today's society, every kid that plays a sport gets a trophy for just showing up and that is not right. There is more meaning behind a trophy for a kid than what most people think. Getting a first place trophy is a better feeling than getting a participation trophy. Kids should be able to go home and celebrate their first place trophies and realize they accomplished something rather than getting a participation trophy for just being out there.…

    • 350 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Trophy Kids Essay

    • 1123 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In the Trophy Kids documentary, the audience is introduced to a series of obsessive parents who want to see their children excel in their respective sport. The parents are all competitors in their own right through outreaching their resources to get their child the best equipment, putting them in competitive leagues, and second best is not an option in trying to see their child be the best. The parents had their faults as well such as overstraining their children, disregard their feelings because of an imposed or sought dream, keeping the children at arm’s length because admittance of pride in their children’s skill perceived as a stifle for their growth, and a singular focus in the sport where a parent’s outburst could demean the other parent’s…

    • 1123 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Should Kids Get Participation Trophies Clumsily fielding the ball, the young boy throws the ball to the wrong base and gives up a run that lost the game for them. The boy had only gone to six of the practices. He didn’t care that he’d lost the game for the team because he knows he was going to get a medal or a trophy. Some people believe participation trophies and medals are good for kids. On the either side, some believe participation trophies and medals are bad for kids.…

    • 532 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Parents of youth athletes support the idea that there is nothing wrong with giving out an award for doing a good job. These parents think that by doing this it will encourage them to want to do better. They also argue that giving participation awards is worth the cost to give kids a big smile. Despite these reasons, these parents do not realize the harm these trophies can cause. In conclusion giving out participation trophies could possibly hurt the youth athletes.…

    • 549 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The majority of children participate In many extracurricular activities such as soccer, baseball, and dance. At the end of the season, every team has its annual awards night and where the star players would be recognized for their outstanding achievements. Everyone else on the team receives the “glad you tried but you aren 't good enough” trophy. Many children, including myself, fall into this category. As naive little children, many kids do not understand that this is the situation.…

    • 1486 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Trophy Kids Movie Analysis

    • 1808 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Introduction Children have always relied on their parents for guidance and support, expecting their parents to do what is best for the kids. The HBO special documentary “Trophy Kids” follows five children that are training in a sport forced on them by their parents, focusing on how the guidance and discipline from their parents impacts the children physically and psychologically. Many of the children in this movie were forced to play their chosen sport because of the parent’s massive financial, emotional, and time commitment. The parents are often furious when the child does not play to their expectations, they take it personally when the child shows emotion or does not preform at an elite level. This movie displays many social and ethical…

    • 1808 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In “Losing Is Good for You,” Ashley Merryman argues that constantly rewarding children is an all too common and toxic practice in society that needs to be stopped immediately since it degrades the true merit of winning. She insists that losing is an essential experience that is imperative to the development of children and their impressionable mentalities. Although she claims that losing is good for kids, she recognizes that people should be aware of the intellectual and emotional differences that are unique to each child before administering constructive criticism. According to Merryman, adults should stop assuring children that they are all identical winners because it drives them to underachieve, leads them to devalue the success of winning,…

    • 802 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Time Kevin Almost Made Cromwell Happy "His dad shrugged. ‘You're not makin' a good case here, Kev.’" Kevin just sat there in disbelief that his dad wouldn’t pay for some classes he wants for Cromwell. "Dad please, at least give me one chance to prove to you that this will make Cromwell more obedient, Please dad." Kevin was sure that if he begged, his dad would allow him to take Cromwell to classes.…

    • 858 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    There has been controversy about parents and their involvement in youth sports. The aggressive behaviors by parents during games can lead to them verbally or even physically abusing officials, coaches and other parents. Parent that show violence towards anyone, can result in a greater matter of legality. Also, when parents watch, comments are made towards their child that make them feel pressured while playing. When the competition arises from the game, “loss of human qualities” are portrayed from the parents because they are only worried about the way their own child performs rather than watching the whole team effort.…

    • 1495 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    However, after many years of seeing participation awards, many people are rethinking the benefits. For example, a sixth grader form New Jersey has many trophies, but admitted “I’m not actually so good at sports.” Some people may feel that it builds a child’s self-esteem if everyone gets an award, but kids know they are getting the award because everybody is getting one. Some people also express in the article “Should Everyone get a Prize” that a trophy is one way to encourage a child's efforts. However, the article “Losing Is Good For You” explains that in order to improve a child's self-image it is helpful to develop their abilities as an athlete.…

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays

Related Topics