Analysis Of Steven M. Cahn's Guiding, Grading, And Guarding

Improved Essays
Steven M. Cahn in his article Guiding, Grading, and Guarding, is about several aspects in the life of a Teacher. How to make students comprehend the session’s teachers taught, the problem with the grading system, and the trouble a professor faces controlling a classroom they fear. This article could not be any more accurate about the problems we face in our school systems. Dr. Cahn describes how great teachers not only motivate their students, teach the material at hand, and organize a classroom, but also provide a vision of excellence. Describing how teachers have to enter a new classroom with a goal of the progression of its students in mind. Only then will they know the progression of the student as the course goes along. “Classrooms are …show more content…
The problem with this system is now students worry more about the grade they are aiming for instead of actually comprehending the material the professor is trying to feed them. Cahn believes this traditional system is the best way to grade a student, but with the overall performance of the student. Some students are abysmal at taking test, however soak up the information like a sponge. Other students are good at memorizing the information even if they do not know the information given and pass the exam, but after a week cannot tell you what they have learned. There are certain holes in the grading system and inappropriately most teachers look at the grades in exams to collect how much knowledge a student …show more content…
Many professors, especially in Universities are viewed through a student 's eye. The fact that a teacher 's advancement, reappearance, or tenure is in the hands of a youth is not only incorrect but frightening. Cahn has a very valid point when he states “How are students going to know if the sources the professors use on the material up to date?” Individuals who are not masters in the topic in which you discuss cannot be the ones who tell you how knowledgeable in a topic one is. Cahn brings up a great example of his personal life, describing how he had two separate math classes. One was algebra, and in that class the flow was very slow and repetitive. At the time he felt like he did not gather any new information. Also to a trigonometry course in which was fast paced and very enjoyable. Yet years later he saw that he had remembered almost everything in his algebra class but couldn’t do basic

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The article “From Degrading to De-grading” written by Alfie Kohn, is a very persuasive and informative text. By reading his article you could tell Kohn is intelligent, gets straight to the point, and supports his claims with convincing evidence. Kohn knows how to get his point through text and attacks every idea from different angles. He was particularly obvious that he was against the letter and number grading system. Kohn mentioned many reasons why the current grading system is inappropriate for the student’s education, such as: grades don’t tell much about a student’s knowledge, grades reduce the drive to learn, and grades reduce the drive to challenge…

    • 108 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Harmer (1991,56) that the wise teacher no longer invites students to enter the house of his wisdom, but rather leads them to the threshold of their own mind. In this line, Harmer (1991) and Shulman and Hammerness (2002) clarified that teachers' responsibility is no longer providing students with knowledge, or controlling them in the classroom, but to facilitate learning, to employ inspiring pedagogy that instigates higher-order thinking, to be aware of students' prior knowledge, to organize it in a way engage students in activities, and to observe them and provide corrective feedback. In other words, a teachers' job is not just to stand at the front of the class and lecture. EFL teachers' performance is high on any policy agenda;…

    • 257 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There is no question that the American education system is flawed and is not the most effective to teach students a broad range of academic subjects. Students are graded on the ability to reproduce knowledge onto a piece of paper after days, weeks, or months of studying a topic. The lack of this ability results in failure to earn a passing grade in the subject matter. If the student can reproduce the desired knowledge at a highly proficient rate, they receive a rating that distinguishes them from other students. In “A Young Person’s Guide to the Grading System,” an article written by Jerry Farber, a professor of English at the University of California at San Diego, the grading system is put at fault for the flawed educational system.…

    • 1079 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Timothy Miller Case Study

    • 1083 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Praise of an Angelic Teacher; Kathy Miller chooses not to rule the world Before addressing the absolutely critical need for all students to pursue the love of Kathy Miller, it is important to realize the greatness that Mrs. Miller has achieved. In all of her years at Banjo High School she has perfected the junior SAT, and in her humbleness she would never lead you to believe that she was the cause of this massive jump in the SAT averages. She has also been a steady member of the Soccer Club for many years, never once convincing them that she had enough power to pressure them into making her child the starting goalie. No sir, Kathy has been faithful and has never once used tenure as an excuse to lazily teach or become enthralled in the power…

    • 1083 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In this article the author, Erickson, discusses the practice of teachers basing student’s grades off of their averages. The topic of the article explains it all, “How Grading Reform Changed”, this article discusses just that. According to Erickson, he suggests that grading reforms at Minnetonka High School led to a change in the way the school system worked. It fundamentally altered how teachers graded, and how students approached their learning. What automatically catches my attention is the example the author gave in relation to the topic.…

    • 777 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    To Grade or Not to Grade? “The real threat to excellence is not grade inflation at all; it is grades.” –Alfie Kohn, The Dangerous Myth of Grade Inflation Sullen-eyed, sleepless zombies stagger throughout the endless corridors. Their minds remain blank, except for their one goal: the biggest, juiciest brains. These brains are what they live for.…

    • 895 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Through the history and evolution of education, mentors have struggled over the best way to challenge their students to reach their peak. Although there are countless methods that have been debated and finessed, the use of the traditional grading scale seems to be a large source of current disputes. Some teachers argue that such a fixed system of testing and ordering pits students against each other, creating an air of competition that should not exist in the classroom. It gives a child a number and tells them how “good” they are. Other educators say that this is not necessarily detrimental.…

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Kohn's Article Analysis

    • 62 Words
    • 1 Pages

    Through all of this, recovery is still a possibility, Kohn in his article suggest solutions the problems that plague students while trying to achieve the highest grade possible. In his article, Kohn discusses the possibility of removing the grading system altogether and replacing it with a focus on learning, rather than achieving the highest grade with not effecting the chance of getting…

    • 62 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    I agree with Kohn’s argument about grading, in his writing passage, “From Degrading to De-Degrading.” I look at grading students in a negative aspect due to the effects it gave my performance in learning. Looking back in my high school career, I remember only studying when I knew I had upcoming tests. When I would study, I would study…

    • 408 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Someone once said that if they ran a school, they would give the average grades to the students who gave all the right answers for being good parrots but they would give the top grades to those who made a lot of mistakes and talked about them, and then discussed what they learned from them. This quote is the polar opposite of the current American grading system. The students who end up getting the top grades are those who give to right answers without learning any of the material. They repeat the answer like a "good parrot" and don't end up absorbing the information.…

    • 1651 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Grades are designed to be a punishment and reward system - if a student works diligently and studies efficiently, or if a student is lazy and irresponsible, their grades reflect as such. However, there are always faults to every system. Valerie J. Janesick discusses in her book how there are teachers who constantly impose practice tests upon their pupils so their students would learn tricks and patterns to the answers such as, “Three in a row, no, no, no.”…

    • 1366 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    As a teacher, I will provide reasoning to the students of why they are doing what they are doing and setting expectations that they will need to fulfill. Students need to be help accountable for their work so they can gain responsibility for their future. I will not give the students busy work that won’t be graded. I will remind the students that it wasn’t too long ago that I was a student studying to become a teacher. I want the students to feel as though any work I give them is only being given to help them grow academically.…

    • 903 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Grades should be considered degrading and unacceptable in measuring a child’s learning development progress What if I told you that every single day that kids go to school, they are not prepared for life, but for standardized tests? Would you believe me? How could that be possible? When kids go to school they learn things, right? They accumulate knowledge for their future.…

    • 1210 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    When we enter into the classroom every day and prepare our lesson plans, we are doing more than just repeating material from a book. We are sharing our personal knowledge with those who will one day control the world. We put a little piece of ourselves in every student we encounter. Whether or not we actually influence them is up to the student. Therefore we must make every possible effort to make a huge impact on their lives each and every…

    • 1272 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Grading And Reporting

    • 1035 Words
    • 5 Pages

    There are many effective reasons to abolish grading systems in schools. One reason is that students are focusing on getting the best grades without understanding the content and they focus on…

    • 1035 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays