Analysis Of Jeremy Waldron's Homelessness And The Issue Of Freedom

Great Essays
In “Homelessness and the Issue of Freedom,” Jeremy Waldron attempts to refute a common criticism leveraged against those who argue that homeless citizens are less free than others—namely, that those who claim the homeless are less free than others appeal to a “positive” conception of freedom. Given that many seminal political philosophers including Hobbes and Hayek advance a “negative” conception of freedom, this criticism likely received traction among those who are well-versed in the history of political thought. Waldron’s aim is thus to reframe the conversation about homelessness in terms of “negative” freedom and to argue that homeless citizens are still less “negatively” free than other citizens. In doing so, Waldron builds on discussions …show more content…
One suggestion that Rawls may be receptive to Waldron’s argument for considering freedom in terms of space lies in his list of essential liberties. Rawls explicitly states that among the right to freedom of speech and association, “the right to hold personal property” is one of the essential liberties a person has (Rawls 53). This is particularly important since Rawls’ conception of justice is broken down into two main principles: the first includes the essential liberties belonging to all members of society and the second includes the distribution of resources that determines the ability of individuals to exercise their essential liberties. He argues that the first principle takes priority over the second principle, since “the basic equal liberties protected by the first principle cannot be justified, or compensated for, by greater social and economic advantages” (Rawls 53-54). This hierarchical ordering suggests that Rawls likely considers property to be as essential of a component of freedom as Waldron does and that Rawls would likely be receptive to Waldron’s introduction of the spatial element of freedom. It also complements Waldron’s broader goal in discussing freedom, space, and homelessness. Waldron is particularly concerned with what he considers to be an encroachment on the freedom of homeless people—that public property laws are prioritizing the well-off members of society over the homeless by preventing the homeless from taking care of basic needs (i.e. stopping homeless citizens from sleeping on park benches). Rawls may argue that these laws are unjust since they prioritize the second principle over the first; they provide social advantages for the rich (i.e. not having to deal as much with ‘gross’ homeless people) at the detriment of the basic needs of

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    Julie Adkin 's “The View from the Front Desk: Addressing Homelessness and the Homeless in Dallas” explores upon the prevalent homelessness issue by studying one of the meanest cities; Dallas. She explores the misconceptions of homelessness and the homeless by expanding in depth about the reality of their situation. Adkin also discusses the reactions and actions taken by governmental agencies and nongovernmental agencies to alleviate the extremity of the persistent problem. Two important points she stresses is the lack of opportunities and resources the homeless have and the problem with the strategies used by national and local agencies to deal with the rampant homelessness issue. Clearly, the problem of homelessness is not adequately dealt…

    • 1113 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Visualize yourself unemployed receiving a final note from a bank, stating that within a week all occupants of the house have to dislodge. In consequence, you will become homeless, a parasite to society. without any place to go and rest, you have to trespass a bridge or rest on a bench, now you are committing a crime and surely you will be imprisoned as criminal that you are product of your economic collapse. A majority of homeless individuals have been suffering such harsh reality due to their poverty. Barbara Ehrenreich, a political activist and author in her essay “Is it Now a Crime Being Poor?” discusses the problems of the US correctional system about the treatment of homeless people.…

    • 1147 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In America, prosperous citizens go to work, grocery shop, and sometimes even live by those who are in abject poverty and homeless. Homelessness is a continuous reminder of the inadequacies of the American economic system. I argue that there is a subpopulation in America whose reality is juxtaposed to that of the middle-class American, and because of this they…

    • 365 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In the article, “Homeless, Mike Dick Was 51, Looked 66,” author Kevin Fagan stated that “The nation needs to commit, emotionally and economically, to saving these older folks” (321.) The older folks referred to in the article are homeless people that live across the United States. Fagan maintained that the nation can do better in terms giving back to the needy, especially considering the wealthy of the nation. However, what Fagan failed to mention in the article is what the homeless are not doing for themselves. Long time homelessness is a predicament that can only be blamed on the homeless because people that wind up homeless for whatever reasons are capable of changing their situation.…

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In his informative essay “Camping for Their Lives,” Scott Branford discusses the political, economic, and social ramifications inflicted upon homeless Americans due to the issue of expensive housing. Bransford purpose in his piece is to dismiss the negative view held toward arising tent cities by highlighting their communal values that can potentiality model future urban development. Branford’s essay can be observed as a criticism due to the topics that are covered such as low wages, rising cost of housing, ethnic exclusion, and lack of government assistance. Consequently, the target audience of his piece is the American people who find the homeless responsible for their own vulnerable economic position rather than being empathized and supported…

    • 828 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In 2015, the city of Boise began ticketing and arresting the homeless for the lone fact that they lacked a permanent place to live. Going out of its way to create new laws banning common behaviors associated with the homeless community, such as lying down in public, sharing food, and sitting on the sidewalk. Rather than dealing with the issue of homelessness head on Boise chose to harass the homeless with the hopes that they would gather their things and leave. For a short span of time, this method did act as a ‘resolution' for Idaho’s high homeless rates. However in time the rates were put back in its original place as the homeless community found methods to avoiding the strict policies.…

    • 253 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The steadily increasing rate of homelessness in Chicago is a social justice issue that is difficult to ignore. It is nearly impossible to walk down Michigan Avenue without noticing the countless shivering, hungry people begging for spare change. But the people we see on our everyday route to school and work are only a very small portion of the thousands of people suffering throughout the city. The National Health Care for the Homeless Council defines homelessness as “…an individual without permanent housing who may live on the streets; in a shelter, mission, single room occupancy facilities, abandoned building or vehicle; or in any other instable or non-permanent situation”(1). Chicagoans may think they know about the issue of homelessness…

    • 2068 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    My parents relocated my siblings and I from Quetzaltenango, Guatemala to San Diego, California in order to allow us to lead a prosperous future. Unlike children in Guatemala, we were presented with an excellent education in San Diego and indulged in learning. For as long as I can recall, discovering new facts and learning new things about the world fascinated me; consequently, I quickly began wanting to help others in their pursuit of learning. I was always the first to offer help to my struggling peers and would stay behind during recess to assist them. My acts were fueled by the desire to see students succeed and I would do anything to help them prosper.…

    • 600 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    History Of Homelessness

    • 1340 Words
    • 6 Pages

    What’s the first thing that the human mind thinks of when the words homeless individual is brought up? Is it a middle aged man on the side of the road with ripped pants and a torn up coat, or is it a mother struggling to keep her family alive? It was recognized that the starting point of homelessness is followed back to when the pilgrims originated during the 1640’s, homeless people during this time period were considered dangerous and police were always on the hunt for them. In addition to this, towns during this time like Baltimore and Philadelphia had an increased number of homeless people than any town in America.…

    • 1340 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many homeless people work full time jobs at minimal pay and still cannot afford to put a roof over their head. The nation’s economic crisis has deeply affected the lives of millions of Americans. Society casts out the homeless. Karl Marx’s conflict theory says there are two classes the owners and the workers. The workers rely on the owners to for their basic needs and the owners are only concerned with personal wealth.…

    • 788 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    They identify policies as a key factor when addressing homelessness; they state that “Workable and effective policies addressing homelessness need to be based on a clear definition of homelessness.” They go on to state that “older outdated policies only address minimal issues of homelessness and failing to recognize the dynamics involved will result in less effectiveness. “Good practice” policy incorporates changing how homelessness is seen and by addressing the housing psychological and social needs of the homeless, as well as integrating across programs and increasing independence through capacity building.” Another key factor related to the homeless issue is inequality among residents. Greene, S., Pendall, R., Scott, M., & Lei, S. (2016) argue that “cities drive economic growth in high-income countries, creating hubs of innovation and generating an outsized share of national wealth.”…

    • 1442 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Homelessness In America

    • 1355 Words
    • 6 Pages

    (J. David Goodman and Nikita Stewart) These examples exemplify the failures and help to show no alleviation to the homeless that has been happening in the U.S. governmental…

    • 1355 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Lens On Homelessness

    • 1298 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Homelessness from a Social Lens Homelessness is a growing concern in the United States, as 7-12 million adults have been homeless at some point in their lives (Markos, Lima, Homelessness). An important question that has been presented is, why should the government adopt financial aid as a solution to homelessness in American cities? This is a very crucial question to think about, as homelessness continues to grow everyday. Overall, it is shown that once people become homeless it is nearly impossible for them to return to their previous lives. From a social lens, adopting financial aid will change the way that all groups of society are affected by homelessness.…

    • 1298 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For many years, society has looked down upon the homeless because of their social status. People have been given the notion that the homeless are in the situation that they’re in because of many taboos that society looks down upon like alcohol, drugs, and gambling. People should be showing the homeless compassion and offer help, instead are met with mean actions and awful words towards their way of life. Not all homeless people are in their situation because of addictions. There are a great number of homeless people out there who are veterans that struggle with mental disorders that they received from past wars, such as PTSD, that do not allow them to live a normal life.…

    • 820 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In a world filled with materialism, self obsession, and greed, it is easy for people to forget what truly matters. At the core of human existence, it is undeniable that people cannot survive alone. In order for civilizations to thrive and endure, people must look out not only for their own self, but for other people as well. Today, we live in a world where this problem is undoubtedly apparent, proven by the amount of homeless families and people across the globe. Homelessness is a major social and economic problem that has intrigued my curiosity, and challenged me to discover more.…

    • 462 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays