Shelby Steel On Affirmative Action Analysis

Superior Essays
Shelby steels view’s on affirmative action aligns with the neo-conservative view. He recaps on the theory explaining that affirmative action and other entitlement programs stem from the presence of white liberal guilt. He recognizes this as the guilt which roots from the ill- intentions and actions of their ancestors which motivates them to sponsor and advocate for these government assistance programs. White liberals believe that by installing a program, which is intended to elevate the black community in an already developed society, they have indirectly cleared their guilty consciences. Steels states, “In a very real sense, entitlement programs for blacks serve the personal interests of whites as well.” (Steels. 151) He further analysis …show more content…
Instead solely basing the accomplishments off of their merit, they believe that their position is attainment through public policy. In Steels opinion, liberal victimization and preferential treatment is a detrimental aspect of the black society. Though he feels this way, he is not against all liberal government assistance programs. He advocates for policies which aid the inner-city residents in bettering their own lives and promotes programs that eliminate the horrific conservative view of bootstrapping. He acknowledges and attempts to disintegrate the barriers within the black community. Steels’ ideological view on affirmative action correlates to theories of other neo-conservatives, specifically, Cornel West.

Cornell West addresses the notion of affirmative action through the study of both the Liberal and conservative ideologies. He begins by stating his individual view of both approaches alluding to the idea that both parties failed to realized and understand the true meaning of these programs. He states that, “The liberal notion that more governmental programs can solve racial problems and political problems.”(West. 2) He argues this to be extremely
…show more content…
West focuses on the reasons for creating governmental programs through the eyes of the black community while Steele’s chooses to explain the reasons of creating these programs through the white liberal perspective. Steel’s ideological theories as to why these entitlement programs were initially created, only includes the presence of white guilt, failing to include the elevation rooting from the Civil Rights movements and the Black power ideology. Although they have separate approaches, they both come to a meeting point within their theories on affirmative action. Both philosophers attain the idea that affirmative action is simply a program which takes away from black success corrupting their psychological mindset, and hindering the black community from reaching their full potential by them heavily depending on

Related Documents

  • Great Essays

    These ideologies are set to embrace one’s own kind, support, and uplift each other just as Brooker T. Washington wanted the African-American community to pull themselves up by their boot straps. At the end of the book chapter 4 shift gears in reference to Black…

    • 1188 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Decent Essays

    This essay was written by Richard Rodriguez Titled “It’s class, stupid”. This is about the author voicing his opinion on affirmative action. The essay starts off by saying a professor from texas said something that was offensive to African Americans and Mexicans. He goes on and brings up affirmative action saying it is unfair to poor whites.…

    • 370 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Second, it is certain that affirmative action has benefited a group of people more than others. Initially, affirmative action was meant for federal contractors. Although, they were supposed to employee people without regards to their race, color, or national origin, studies have shown “that affirmative action helps white woman” (Nittle) more than women or men of color. In the Supreme Court case of Abigail Fisher versus the University of Texas, ironically, she is the type of person affirmative action benefits the most. But the ban of affirmative action has not always been a disadvantage for all minorities.…

    • 802 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    It is a well-known fact the African Americans tend to have higher levels of unemployment and lower levels of education than their white counterparts. The constant debate that whether or not that happened because of the structure of laws in the United States or because black people do not have a culture of working hard. In “Revisiting the Debate on Race and Culture”, William Darity Jr. talks about how different aspects of black identity play a role in the education and wealth of an individual. Chapter five of When Affirmative Action was white the author, Ira Katznelson , talks about a bill that contributed to the disparities between the earnings and the standards of living between white Americans and Black Americans. The chapter focused on the…

    • 718 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    When Affirmative Action first came into existence, it was not well received. A lot of scholars did not believe it was necessary. A scholar specifically named Thomas Sowell believed that Affirmative Action had a reversed outcome than what the creators had intended. He asserts that “Policies initiated to help the disadvantaged ended up helping the privileged within the preferred groups instead. Policies intended to insure intergroup harmony led to intergroup resentments and violence.”…

    • 1243 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Great Essays

    Mary Ellen Turpel provides her perspective on how the rule of law is very problematic. Her critique is based on the notion that the concept of the rule of law – that everyone is equal -has been developed and adapted by Western states as a method to restrain the government. Turpel argument is not about the debate of individual and collative right, rather it is about rethinking how we think and fundamentally how we perceive our rights. It is important that Ontario Human Rights Code does not undermine other people’s human rights because they do not belong to the so-called dominant group. Her argument is that one cannot understand the difference of cultural relevance without letting go over your cultural view.…

    • 1286 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    1. The Supreme Court decisions in a case affect significantly the entire country’s legal system. Therefore, models of judicial decision making were created to explain the Supreme Court’s behavior and how they influence policies. While the legal, attitudinal and the strategic model are not the only theories of judicial decision making, those constitute the most prevalent hypotheses to explain judicial decisions.…

    • 1172 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Argument of Strong Affirmative Action Between Hettinger and Pojman After the era of the Civil Rights Movement swept how people think, Americans and business have tried to find ways in order to help promote diversity and equality into establishments such as the workforce and higher education. One of the ways that America has decided to do this is by promoting affirmative Action. Affirmative action a policy favoring those who tend to suffer from discrimination, also know as positive discrimination. We encounter two authors that both seem to have different opinions on the view of affirmative action. Edwin C. Hettinger is on the side calling affirmative action “reverse racism” itself suggests that it is discrimination: discrimination towards…

    • 1047 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    In “The Case Against Affirmative Action,” Louis Pojman argues against Strong Affirmative Action, which he distinguishes from Weak Affirmative Action. I will begin this paper by explaining this distinction between Strong and Weak Affirmative Action. Second, I will explain why I agree with Pojman that Strong Affirmative Action has no moral weight. Next, I will provide an exposition of Argument 9: An Argument from the Principle of Human Merit. In this exposition, I will explain why I agree with the two pillars of Pojman’s argument.…

    • 1564 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Racial Inequality

    • 1272 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Wilson (2011) identifies an emerging form of racism known to social scholar as “laissez faire racism”, as the belief that blacks are responsible for their own socio-economic circumstances and therefore are undeserving of any outside aid. This school of thought and those sharing a distasteful views towards black people result in “devastating effects of oppression is that it dehumanizes the oppressed people” (Osajima, 1998, p.153). These views ultimately believe that blacks are culturally inferior. With the media constantly portraying black males as the one-dimensional aggressors of crime and predators, it is difficult for certain offensive stereotypes to not develop. Racial tensions between blacks and mainstream American society forming from an inadequate understanding of the reality and causes of ghetto culture continue to set back black people’s progress in the nation.…

    • 1272 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    Affirmative Action Case Study

    • 1561 Words
    • 7 Pages
    • 4 Works Cited

    However, he notes, “truly meeting the needs of low-income students would require fundamental reforms in financial aid.” He alludes to the early days of the Penn Grant, which in the beginning covered 84% of college expenses, making attending college for the poor a real possibility. Today, the Penn Grant covers half that, or only 42% of the costs of college. For many low-income families, sending their kids to college has become a financial impossibility. Many poor students end up going to community colleges, the cheaper alternative.…

    • 1561 Words
    • 7 Pages
    • 4 Works Cited
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Many Southern whites strongly felt that giving African Americans an education would give them “false notions of equality.” This belief led to a segregation of black and white schools being instituted, which demonstrates the bigotry that African Americans experienced even after the enforcement of the new amendments. When it came to employing African Americans, many were offered almost no opportunities. Companies such as tobacco, iron, and lumber manufacturers often gave blacks the most degrading and lowest-paid positions. It is evident, that African Americans were not treated equally compared to whites because of the limited work they were given.…

    • 548 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Louis P. Pojman argues in his article, The Case against Affirmative Action, that even in extreme cases reverse racism and strong affirmative action are wrong. Pojman differentiates between strong and weak affirmative action and in his article he focus on strong affirmative action. Pojman defines strong affirmative action as preferential treatment to someone based on race, ethnicity, or gender in favor of the under represented groups to get equal rights. The first argument made for affirmative action that Pojman disagrees with is the role model argument.…

    • 813 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Racial Formation Theory

    • 750 Words
    • 3 Pages

    While this problem affects all racial minorities, the most pressing issue raised by these scholars is the history of slavery, forced labor, and systematic disenfranchisement and exclusion experienced by African Americans that has never been addressed to the fullest possible extent. A new theoretical conceptualization of race and racism that challenges neoliberal racism with both ideological transformation and macro-(or state-)level socioeconomic structural changes is needed to effectively address this legacy of racial oppression. Focusing exclusive on either the ideology or material inequality will eventually allow room for newly mutated form of racism to thrive as it has happened with the development of neoliberalism and new political conservative rhetoric since the civil rights…

    • 750 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Louis P. Pojman uses the article, “The Case Against Affirmative Action,” to address why he is against Affirmative Action. Affirmative Action is where people take steps to increase the number of women, or people of color in situations like education and employment because, they were a part of a group that were discriminated against. One solid argument that he has is known as the role model argument. In the role model argument, he argues, “We all have need of role models, and it helps to know that others like us can be successful.” (pg. 468)…

    • 913 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays