“Elementary, my dear Watson.” Sherlock Holmes’s famous catchphrase is still widely recognized throughout modern society. Much to his own surprise, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle became one of the most famed authors in the field of crime fiction after the creation of British private detective Sherlock Holmes and his associate Dr. John Watson. Even though the novels and short stories were published during the late 1800’s, people today still consider Holmes the most well-known detective of all time. The dynamic duo’s profound effect on society has led to thousands of adaptions of the mysteries on stage, television, movies, and books. One of the popular adaptations to date is the BBC’s hit show SHERLOCK, which takes place in modern London. Most of the
…show more content…
While both deal with Irene Adler and her incriminating photos, one key factor differs, which changes the ending of the mystery. In Doyle’s original version, Adler ultimately outwits Holmes. Although Holmes is supposedly unbeatable, Doyle chooses to have a woman outmaneuver him, an intriguing choice in those days. However, the BBC version has Adler outwit Holmes for most of the episode until he solves the case at the last minute. This curious contrast in the portrayal of feminine roles intrigues many readers because Doyle’s society was not as liberal as today’s culture. Even while Adler may not outwit Holmes in the BBC’s interpretation, her personality does not suffer much …show more content…
He is depicted as a tall, slender man with incredible mental abilities and observational skills. While most of his cases seem unsolvable to Scotland Yard or Dr. Watson, Holmes quickly resolves each crisis; thus putting his keen logic on display. Although Doyle chooses to keep his character rather unemotional, the BBC decided on making him less impassive. Both Holmes(s) rarely attend social events, yet when Doyle’s Holmes leaves home he is courteous to those around him. On the other-hand, the BBC’s Holmes is rude, demeaning, and all together tactless with the people around him. As a consequence, the BBC’s Holmes strays from Doyle’s true intention for the character —excited brilliance mixed with detached indifference. However Holmes is portrayed, the end result still captivates audiences the
While both deal with Irene Adler and her incriminating photos, one key factor differs, which changes the ending of the mystery. In Doyle’s original version, Adler ultimately outwits Holmes. Although Holmes is supposedly unbeatable, Doyle chooses to have a woman outmaneuver him, an intriguing choice in those days. However, the BBC version has Adler outwit Holmes for most of the episode until he solves the case at the last minute. This curious contrast in the portrayal of feminine roles intrigues many readers because Doyle’s society was not as liberal as today’s culture. Even while Adler may not outwit Holmes in the BBC’s interpretation, her personality does not suffer much …show more content…
He is depicted as a tall, slender man with incredible mental abilities and observational skills. While most of his cases seem unsolvable to Scotland Yard or Dr. Watson, Holmes quickly resolves each crisis; thus putting his keen logic on display. Although Doyle chooses to keep his character rather unemotional, the BBC decided on making him less impassive. Both Holmes(s) rarely attend social events, yet when Doyle’s Holmes leaves home he is courteous to those around him. On the other-hand, the BBC’s Holmes is rude, demeaning, and all together tactless with the people around him. As a consequence, the BBC’s Holmes strays from Doyle’s true intention for the character —excited brilliance mixed with detached indifference. However Holmes is portrayed, the end result still captivates audiences the