A Clash Of Culture In Heartland America Analysis

Improved Essays
A. THEMES:
• MOVEMENT: By definition, movement, one of the five themes of geography, is characterized by the transfer of people, ideas, and culture, and things over space. In “A Clash of Culture in Heartland America,” Stephen G. Bloom excellently portrays the reluctance and negativity that can be involved with relocation and movement. Specifically, Postville was a picturesque town where all the citizens knew and trusted the other members of their community. In fact, the trust level was so high that many individuals did not lock their car or house doors. Additionally, these individuals town of this all shared the same basic morals and beliefs, that is until a new group of Jews moved into the community. When a meat-packaging facility was
…show more content…
The three types of region include formal regions, functional regions, and perceptual regions. Specifically in this video, perceptual regions were very prevalent. For example, before all of the immigrants moved into Postville, the town was a quaint vernacular region. This was due to the topophilia that the locals had. Unambiguously, church attendance, maintenance of homes and possessions, and personal character were all things and aspects that all members of the community valued. Because of this, they all took pride of their hometown, region, and self-identity. However, the members also had very strong opinions of others from different parts of the country and world. They believed that their way was the right way, and they had no desire to reach out of their comfort zone and accept cultures and ways of life from different regions. They believed that the newcomers came from a different region in which the values and moral clashed with their own, and therefore, were not accepting of the …show more content…
PUSH AND PULL FACTORS:
• PUSH: The push factors mainly applied to those who were originally Postville citizens. This is due to their inflexibility and unwillingness to try and accept new cultures. With these cultures came new religion, language, food, and ways of life. Clearly, these new traits were push factors for the white, American Postville citizens.
• PULL: Clearly, pull factors attracted foreigners and people with different ways of life, specifically the Mexicans and the Jews. These factors included jobs, opportunity, affordability, and education. Some examples include the meat-packaging facility, American citizenship, reduced and free school lunch, etc.

C. MIGRATION AND COUNTER STREAMS:
• MIGRATION: The migrators to Postville Iowa all shared a common origin and purpose. A specific example includes the Jewish man, Aaron Rubashkin, bought the meat packaging facility. In doing so, he moved to Postville to run and operate his own company. However, he was not alone. His move created a ripple effect among other Jews and hard-working Mexicans. These other individuals followed him to the area to help run his company and for a better quality of

Related Documents

  • Superior Essays

    In the article, “Immigrants Keep an Iowa Meatpacking Town Alive and Growing” written by Patricia Cohen, there is discussion regarding a small town in northwestern Iowa which experienced a large influx of migrants over a period of time. Cohen interviews a local resident on his thoughts about the migrants moving in and obtaining many of the local jobs. The resident believed it was one of the best thing to happen to their town, as it allowed their town the opportunity to grow. First, Cohen discusses factors as to why small towns are becoming scarce.…

    • 1201 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    James Gregory’s, American Exodus, is a book that focuses on Dust Bowl migration to California, and their economic and social struggles in California. The book first starts off setting up the historical context of the Dust Bowl and the migrants with statistics, maps, pictures, and migrant backgrounds in the introduction. The overall book reads like a history textbook on the Dust Bowl, which is divided into two parts instead of narrative based on one family like The Grapes of Wrath. The first part of the book is organized chronologically, focusing on the resettlement of the Dust Bowlers, and the second part is done thematically and focuses on Okie culture. Gregory’s approach successfully showed the clash of cultures and social struggles the migrants faced in California accurately without having to caricaturize the migrants.…

    • 828 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Skill: Infer and Support the Main Idea PILSEN 7th Grade Nonfiction Center for Urban Education ©2007 Pilsen is an old community in Chicago with a long history. This part of Chicago started small and got bigger, as most neighborhoods in the city did.…

    • 672 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    In the 1700 The Scottish were trying to leave scotland to go to america because of a war.the brittish were trying to keep the scots for war. This falure of the brittish trying to get the scots to war is a example of a push factor.when the war was beginning and the brittish were tring to recruit some didnt want to fight in the war so they left this is a example of a pull factor.this essay will show you the push and pull factors of why the scots went to america. my first push factor is the British were pushing the Scottish into fighting in the war so they tried to escape it and go to America. The reason I will show you this push factor is it shows what they went through to leave a country to go to America.…

    • 437 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Great Essays

    The Midwest, a place in the world where communities are closely aligned to one another. These small, rural communities rely on every person in order to create that community. It seems as though that knowing everyone around the small communities was what made a person successful in life. Additionally, these communities valued hard-work and honesty when it came with almost everything they did in their lives; whether it was working in the farmlands or spreading information throughout the communities about certain people to look out for, it was hard to be anonymous inside the city. Unfortunately, there are sometimes citizens that do not look forward to that kind of lifestyle.…

    • 1476 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Three ways the environment affects the people are it’s cold weather, rain and flooding, and it’s very windy. Flooding can cost humans lots of money especially in areas with high concentrations of people. Two political issues currently involving Chicago is the cover-up of a teen shooting that happened last year and whether or not the mayor of Chicago should resign. By using the five themes of geography, one can get a good idea of what an area’s characteristics as explained in this paper.…

    • 612 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    o what extent was isolationisms the main factor changing attitudes towards immigration Before the 19th century America had an open door policy meaning anyone could enter the country regardless of background or religion. Old immigrants came from northern and western Europe. But by the tun of the 19th century new immigrants from poorer areas of Europe like Easter and Southern Europe started to arrive in America looking for a better life. Many consider isolationism the most important factor in changing attitudes towards immigrants.…

    • 1679 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During the period 1840 to 1929, the United States’ population was on a significant rise due to a major increase in immigrants. An increased combination of “pushes” and “pulls” improved migrations throughout the United States. Some push factors included poverty of farmers, overcrowding in cities, and religious persecution. Positive reasons for moving to the United States, or pull factors, included political and religious freedom, economic opportunities, and the abundance of industrial jobs in U.S. cities. There were many different reactions that came about from the increased migration of immigrants.…

    • 1157 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    When widespread immigration to the New World began, the immigration was not an equal distribution of people of all motives and cultures. People immigrated to certain areas of the New World based on what they hoped to achieve there. Some people were seeking relief from religious persecution, while others hoped to make a fortune in the new, abundant land. These varying motives lead to people with similar motives settling near other people with similar beliefs. One group of these people tended to immigrate to the region known today as New England.…

    • 608 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The author of the written passage, “The Horizontal World”, Debra Marquart utilizes the rhetorical strategies of bleak imagery and ethos to initially encourage harmful stereotypes of the upper Midwest and later prove that region, where she grew up in, is in fact special. Marquart describes the region’s topology, famous trivialities such as it being in several movies, and even political stance. However, she does so by at first describing its physical characteristics with disgust and even with hints of disdain in order to support her intended audience’ existing viewpoint that the Midwest is simply a “fly-over” region in the United States with no real significance to it. Given her credibility as a midwesterner herself, being acquainted with all…

    • 764 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The pull factors include democracy, freedom, tolerance, peace. Other cultural factors can include education and health. The final factor is environmental factors which are considered involuntary. The push factor includes natural disasters, earthquakes, tsunamis, volcanoes, and climate change. The pull factors is a place that is relatively safe from natural…

    • 778 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Parents are responsible for creating an identity in their children based on their cultures and values, until every child grow up and adopt a new identity based on their tastes and motivations. Most of the time people take their new identities according to what they see around them, different cultures, styles and / or languages. School, friendships, and different cultures bring a great help for people who are not able to find their identity. The dominant cultures form much of the change of identity of a person, even when their cultures are not dominant. In the United States the dominant culture is the white culture; Many people like the idea of belong to a culture that for many years been known as a dominant culture and as a powerful culture…

    • 219 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Recently we were given two articles “The Gilded Age” by T. Jackson Lears and “The Rise of Industrial America, 1877-1900” by Richard White along with the video from the Gilder Lehrman Institute of American History to read and watch. All of these resources allowed me to get a better understanding of the things going on during the Industrialization or “The Gilded Age”. For instance both articles collectively highlighted westward expansion, cultural and social shifts, the government's failure to recognize African-Americans as the white Americans equal equals , immigrants and economical changes. While these articles share a lot in common with one another they both share very few commonalities besides the involvement of the struggles African-Americans…

    • 711 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Place also includes human characteristics. This can be a state to a…

    • 1000 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    This culture has norms and codes that they believe in, such as steeling from everyone. It is how these members were…

    • 2774 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Superior Essays