50 Years Of Stupid Grammar Advice Summary

Superior Essays
Many things can happen in the span of 50 years. In this case, Geoffrey K. Pullum argues for 50 years a certain book has influenced university graduate’s understanding of grammar. Pullum is the author of the article “50 Years of Stupid Grammar Advice”, which is primarily discussing the book “The Elements of Style” by William Strunk and E. B. White. , Pullum argues that this highly regarded book misguides student’s understanding of English grammar. Pullum goes into detail about how the book incorrectly teaches grammar especially when the authors are warning to avoid many things. Whether the advice was even correct or not, it has influenced student’s writing to the extent where they avoid forming sentences that do not seem grammatically correct to only themselves. This discussion arises many points of grammar’s role in writing. I strongly agree with Pullum that grammar should not restrict our writing and instead be used as a tool to expand our own ability. Aside from this book we can see the influence of the modern ‘text language’ is further ruining student’s understanding of grammar. Grammar is an essential writing tool that can improve our writing ability as opposed to restricting it.
Grammar is a tool that
…show more content…
Pullum has shown how White and Strunk’s book “The Elements of Style” has misguided students by acting as opinionated grammar rule book. The unintentional consequences of this book are that student’s grasp of grammar will become limited, which also limits their creative potential. This also relates to the wider issue of how ‘text language’ is becoming mainstream, which is also limited student’s grammatical and communication abilities. Collectively these will, unfortunately, shape the English Language to a simpler form of itself, unless students continue to properly study the English language and English

Related Documents

  • Decent Essays

    In “It Ain’t We, Babe” by Lucy Ferriss, published in Chronicle of Higher Education, 8 April 2015,Ferrisss gainsays the review established by Princeton Review’s practice. She contends that proper grammar is not always appropriate or particularly suited within “language in real life”. Using various song lyrics and artists she perceives to disprove that proper grammar is needed to convey meaning and inadvertently proves that it can confuse a reader or audience, she additional comments on modern grammar and gives an alternative suggestion to…

    • 84 Words
    • 1 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    Argumentative Essay on Grammar I believe grammar should be emphasized in the school district. So that when the children at that school have a better chance of getting through college and getting a job. Some jobs make it to where you have to have good grammar to get the job. As well as colleges if you don’t have good grammar in college it would make you look bad.…

    • 398 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Decent Essays

    After reading the article by Kyle Wiens, I actually felt quite troubled, unproportionally so for its harmless subject matter. Based on the article, Wiens almost seems to have a haughty air about him, in my opinion. I cannot exactly pinpoint at which particluar section of the article leads me to have this impression, but I believe just the general idea of the article that is not hiring qualified people based on their grammar skills), and the fact that Wiens is a self-proclaimed "grammar stickler" is what I find irksome. While I know that good grammar is extremely important, I also know that grammar, in any language, is arbitrary. So when I read about people placing quite a lot of value into grammar, I frankly find it annoying and find said people to be overly condescending.…

    • 490 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Decent Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Bruce Ballenger argue in his essay that students focus mostly on the conventions than the writing itself. The author effectively persuades the audience to recognize the conventions through emotions and credibility. Bruce Ballenger, is a college professor who teaches english at a university. He explains an experience about his eighth teacher, Mrs. O’Neill, who hammered into her students the importance of good grade. This strengthens his reputation by the use of his own experience in writing ,as well as, mentions his own experiences with harsh english teachers.…

    • 817 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Writing Etiquette While reading the letters written by Abigail and John Adams, I noticed that they were written differently than if someone from today’s society had written them. They were written well, clearly thought out and pleasantly worded. There may have been an occasional misspelled word; however, despite that, it is obvious that both Adams were highly intelligent. It is a shame that people today do not give the same careful attention to their written communications. Writing properly has become a lost art.…

    • 430 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In Michaela Cullington’s “Does Texting Affect Writing?” Cullington discusses the views individuals have on texting and how it impacts student’s writing. The growing popularity of texting has caused external and internal dissonance amongst several groups with different perspectives on how it affects writing. Some defend that it has some positive effects on writing in general. Others argue that it has a negative impact, specifically on formal writing.…

    • 704 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    One of my quirkiest traits―and a consistent topic of laughter amongst my friends―is my ever-present and never-fading habit of texting with perfect grammar. Semicolons, commas, and colons all make an appearance in my texting, a side effect of wanting to be a book editor when I grow up. Some might argue that because I use texting as a form of communication, my writing skills have regressed. Others argue that texting has actually benefitted my formal writing skills. In Michaela Cullington’s article, “Does Texting Affect Writing?”…

    • 1287 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    During this summer session of ENGL101A, I have learned multiple ways to express myself through my writing. In fact, before signing up for this class, I did not know the proper way to compose an academic essay for a particular audience, and how to properly cite my sources. Nevertheless, after the short summer session, I am able to define my purpose and audience, analyze critically any piece of information, and write with proper citations and fewer grammatical errors with confidence. Through the short time of 5 weeks, I learned how to focus on my audience as well as how to define the purpose of my papers as academically as possible.…

    • 577 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The author also presents a possible argument to his point of view that will be addressed later in the article: “Isn’t grammar really a thing of the past, and isn’t the new idea to communicate in any way as long as you can make yourself understood” (Simon 334)? This is an idea that some members of his intended audience might agree with, which encourages them to read on to find out what makes that idea so wrong. The goal of Simon’s use of the rhetorical question is to really open the mind of the reader in order to more effectively promote his ideas later in the article. This way, the reader is slightly groomed before being exposed to evidence that supports John Simon’s…

    • 1284 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Edward Finegan argues that there is no right or wrong when it comes to language. Finegan says that, “English is now changing in exactly the same ways that have contributed to making it the rich, flexible, and adaptable language so popular throughout the world today.” Finegan describes descriptive and prescriptive views of language to argue that English is not falling apart, but simply changing as time progresses. John Simon, on the other hand, argues that “good English” needs to be preserved because any other form of English is a product of ignorance. Finegan starts off his argument by analyzing descriptive and prescriptive grammar.…

    • 1087 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The article of concern here is Does Texting Affect Writing? by Michaela Cullington. The research paper examines the effects of texting on students’ academic writing. In Cullington’s findings, she concludes that texting has a minimal effect on writing.…

    • 974 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    That perhaps the taboo of technology creating a dumber generation is in fact a misrepresentation. This is explained when Lunsford expresses that, “Young people are for the most part aware of the context and audience for their writing” (Lunsford 572). In other words, students are choosing on their own free will to alter their writing style. That the decision to not use proper punctuation or sentence structure isn’t because of the effects of technology, but more of a deliberate and calculated decision to express one’s character. It is further explained that regardless of the various types of writing styles, ultimately students are learning more through what she called “life writing” or writing outside of school curriculums.…

    • 980 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Different styles of writing can be created but you cannot change the grammar. In his essay “How to Say Nothing in 500 Words”, Paul Roberts shows us we can correctly use the English language in our writings. He believes “the principles of good writing should remain constant”. (Roberts). In most colleges, most students do not possess the level of writing and reading skill that is necessary to be successful in their courses.…

    • 1214 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Written language is a trait known to be only possessed by mankind. Although other species may have audible forms of communication, man is able to record and document his thoughts, feelings, or events that have unfolded in a way that can be viewed multiple times without him having to use his voice over and over. Literacy is a skill that adults in the United States are expected to have; but the level of your literacy says a lot about you and can have a tremendous impact on what career you end up in. For this reason, this college English class is a requirement for all those seeking a degree. Not only did I learn how to think of subjects and topics more objectively, but I learned a multitude of different modes and strategies I can employ in my writing.…

    • 1032 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    They argue that there are five key principles that underlie the various critical approaches to teaching basic writers. These principles included assuming all students are capable of learning, engage students in student-centered work, address “higher order” issues alongside “lower-ordered” issues, integrate academic writing and reading instruction, and embrace the conflict between what they already know and what they need to learn (21). Mutnick and Lamos suggest that there are four major basic writer pedagogical approaches that go with theoretical changes since its conception. One of the four approaches is error centered, which is based on Shaughnessy’s theory of the logic of errors. They focus on the student’s errors he/she produces, view Standard Written English as “normative and neutral rather than ideological and culturally biased” and are still used to help students learn grammar conventions (22).…

    • 922 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays