2000 Nextcard Audit Case Summary

Decent Essays
1. Should auditors evaluate the soundness of a client’s business model? Defend your answer.
We are in agreeance that auditors should evaluate the soundness of a client’s business model. This would be an essential part of auditor’s inherent risk assessment process. The risk assessment is to understand the entity, its environment, and internal control to identify and assess the risk of material misstatement whether due to fraud or error at the financial statement and relevant assertion levels (AU-C Section 315, 2015)
2. Identify and briefly describe the specific fraud risk factors present during the 2000 NextCard audit. How should these factors have affected the planning and execution of that engagement?
I totally agree with your response to this question. You described some of the fraud risk factors present during the 2000 Nextcard audit. You could have added one additional fraud risk factor that Nextcard had a weak internal control environment. NextCard intentionally underestimated the allowances for bad debt. And denied it was due to high credit losses but stated it was due to fraud schemes (Knapp, 2015)
3. What are the primary objectives an audit team hopes to accomplish by preparing a proper set of workpapers?
I agree with your response to this question. You answered the question in the same manner in which I would have. I think
…show more content…
I like how you listed all ten of the auditing standards according to AU Section 150 in order to give us the readers a better understanding. I agree with you on three principles violated by the E&Y auditors in this case. I would like to add two additional standards I feel E&Y auditors violated. AS No. 4 Reporting on Whether a Previously Reported Material Weakness Continues to Exist. NextCard understated allowance for bad debit for each reporting period. AS No. 10 Supervision of the audit engagement. The team of auditor’s helped conceal NextCard’s financial problems and altered

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The auditors could have detected this embezzlement and fraud by performing additional audit procedures for cash and inventory. With respect to cash-skimming scheme, the auditor could investigate further on the “Office” line item of certain cash report sheets by inquiring the company’s personnel and the management. Similarly, the auditor could also use analytical procedures to gain an overall assessment of sales and profitability across individual stores. Because the cash receipt was taken into consideration in determining sales and profitability of stores affected by the embezzlement, stores that consistently exhibit relatively lower sales and profitability may raise auditor’s eyebrows. Additionally, since the cash-skimming operation was not…

    • 774 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    For public, business, and other practices, the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct has different Rules for those practices. As for public practice, independence is a required rule but not for CPAs in business and other practices. It is important because there are always some circumstances or relationship occurring to threat the Code compliance so that the public interest will be put at risk. For CPA firms, before they sign the engagement letters with clients, they must make sure the independence of the CPAs and the firms will not be impaired. At this point, auditors can use the conceptual framework to evaluate the relationship or circumstance to decide whether provide service or not.…

    • 1021 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The question boils down to whether the transactions suspected of being fraudulent are valid or not. In order to have the best outcome, we want to search further than the suspected transaction and really look into the red flags of the situation and try to figure out the concealment strategy used. The procedure will look to authenticate, identify, and link to a fraud and/or concealment strategy. Specific audit procedures that may prove useful are analyzing the sales of the company and re-calculating the costs of goods sold in order to see if the calculation matches what is in the account. If the calculations do not line up with what is in the account, we may see that the entries were in fact fraudulent.…

    • 1732 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Peregrine Fraud Case Study

    • 1216 Words
    • 5 Pages

    1) At Peregrine, the risk factors, especially those aligned with control environment factors and the “tone at the top” are discussed. The risks included having a paper based confirmation system for the entire business; no segregation of duties, which meant that only one or very few people were working on the financial statements, and in this case Mr. Wasendorf was the only one and had altered all bank documents using only Photoshop, excel, scanners, and printers. Continuing on, time off was not required at Peregrine, which could have ultimately discovered this fraud much earlier, by allowing someone else to sit in the absentee’s seat and review all of their work. Additionally, Peregrine lacked internal auditors or an audit committee at the time. The presence of the internal auditors could have decreased odds of misstatement incentives to commit fraud by management, called fraudulent financial reporting, and overseen…

    • 1216 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    There are some criticisms about this risk-based approach. For example, this method may not represent a firm’s average audit quality since it focusses on some difficult audits (Church and Shefchik, 2012). However, I think it is fair from…

    • 724 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    First, during an audit, an auditor should ensure that they obtain the appropriate assurance to tackle the audit risk. Many people assume that the information gathered from the third party is more reliable than the evidence collected by the audited company. However, in the case study, the company had already colluded with its suppliers to provide false information to the audit team, and this jeopardized the review process. Therefore, it is advisable for an auditor to ensure that they maintain a professional skepticism by considering previous audit reports and the relationship between the audit client and the third party. Consequently, over-reliance on a third party during an auditing process, although proven to be efficient since it is free from adjustment or influence by the client audit.…

    • 1475 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    All Possible Questions

    • 1955 Words
    • 8 Pages

    BUS 365 WK 7 Quiz 6 Chapter 9 - All Possible Questions To Purchase Click Link Below: http://strtutorials.com/BUS-365-WK-7-Quiz-6-Chapter-9-All-Possible-Questions-BUS3658.htm BUS 365 WK 7 Quiz 6 Chapter 9 - All Possible Questions Chapter 09 Multiple Choice 1. __________ are planning and control systems that capture and record all of the company’s data from operations, and perform the routine transactions needed to conduct business on an ongoing day-to-day basis. a) Operational information systems b) Strategic information systems c) Databases d) Inter-organizational systems 2. Why did the largest Scandinavian food retailer group, Axfood AB, invest 200 million SEK (20.4 million Euros or US$25.6 million) in an IT platform?…

    • 1955 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Inappropriate accounting issues happened in 2015 done by top management overstating company’s earnings by 15.8 billion yen (US$1.2 billion) over seven years since 2008 (Chambers, 2015), forcing Toshiba to perform a financial restatement for the year ended 2008 until 2014 and reforming its corporate governance (Toshiba, 2015). Moroney et al. (2014) revealed that fraud affects auditor judgements in determining the level of significant of audit risk. Likewise, it is argued that auditors tend to release more severe audit opinion when there are more risks inherent like the financial restatements (Qiang, Nanwei, & Gang,…

    • 824 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    First off this risk forces us to assess a lower level of materiality on the audit. In my professional opinion with all of the glaring risks I recommend that we set a performance materiality of $500,000 or .2% of sales, with a planning materiality of $50,000. With such low materiality and high fraud risk all auditors should be experienced staff auditors, and be on high alert of fraudulent information from Apollo employees, and must be diligent in keeping auditing procedures unpredictable as to not allow employees to cover their tracks. With the risks outlined, and the low materiality level we will need to conduct a significant amount of substantive tests, because it is the only way to get the detection risk to an acceptable level with how high the clients control risk is. To do this we will need to perform substantive testing on at least Accounts receivable, sales, Inventory, Accounts payable, expenses, prepaid expenses, and…

    • 1781 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Financial Fraud Case Study

    • 1000 Words
    • 4 Pages

    However, I am personally in agreement with the other findings to closely pay attention to the disclosure statements and textual statements because it is as vulnerable as financial metrics, which provide syntactical cues to conceal fraudulent activity by deliberately misleading financial statement users by purposely using presentation style, uninformative verbiage, complex, difficult and selective accounting terminology, positive tone, passive voice, adverse message and uncertainty markers. On the other hand, on the research results in investigating the techniques on detecting financial fraud, I think is more focus or elaborate on traditional fraud investigation techniques, which involves surprise sampling, site visits to vendors and clients and random testing. The historical fraud investigation strategies could use some enhancement using the highly technological data analytics software and ERP systems. Although, I agree the part where the research implies the importance of in depth knowledge of the business process and policies you are investigating, while performing…

    • 1000 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Superior Essays

    Audit Planning Standards

    • 1118 Words
    • 5 Pages

    For example, AS 2010 has additional consideration regarding the audit activities. First, the nature and extent of planning activities that are necessary depend on the size and complexity of the company, the auditor 's previous experience with the company, and changes in circumstances that occur during the audit. Second, when developing the audit strategy and audit plan, the auditor should evaluate some matters and determine whether they are important to the company 's financial statements and internal control over financial reporting and, if so, how they will affect the auditor 's procedures. These matters include the knowledge about the internal control over the financial reporting, matters affecting the industry, matters relating to the company 's business, the extent…

    • 1118 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Superior Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Chief Audit Executive can bridge the gap and provide enhanced value to stakeholders is by developing the audit universe, which is generated through consultation with senior management and other stakeholders. Therefore, the Chief Audit Executive can begin to bridge the gap and include the stakeholders in the process of what needs to be audited by incorporating issues identified through an enterprise-wide risk assessment or enterprise risk management program. For this reason, ERM allows the internal auditor to facilitate discussions with stakeholders to identify what represents the most significant risks to shareholder value by identifying risk assessment process areas. In addition the internal auditor can focus on vital risks that are of…

    • 786 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Great Essays

    The basic principles of IT value are the on-time and on budget delivery of appropriate quality, which achieves the benefits that were promised. In business terms, this is often translated into a competitive advantage but can be disadvantaged by risk. Taking ownership of risk and giving direction for managing risks is a fundamental aspect of successful governance initiative. Risk is further exaggerated when operating IT services in a multi-disciplinary open access environment such as higher education.…

    • 731 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Wild Eagle Spur Case Study

    • 3117 Words
    • 13 Pages

    The Spur Corporation, a public company, founded by Allen Ambor in 1967, has become one of South Africa’s most renowned franchises4. With approximately 270 outlets in South Africa and 39 internationally, Spur continues to dominate the casual dining industry3. This may be attributed to its implementation and use of specific internal controls and audit procedures in majority of its restaurants. (Wild Eagle Spur in Ruimsig will be used as the main source of information in this report). • Internal Controls…

    • 3117 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Great Essays
  • Great Essays

    Internal audit is responsible for systematically associating enterprise strategy, business model needed by strategy implementation and risk preventing objectives from realization so as to guarantee strategy and business model can cope with risk. (1) Internal audit should first list all the key success factors which make objectives come true and risk factors which may prevent from success. Then, internal audit should list identified key success factors and risk factors (internal and external) which may prevent from success one by one, and analyze and judge to which extent risk factors affect objective realization from perspective of enterprise objective and organizational objective. Including: ① Listing enterprise strategy, so as to analyze strategy appropriateness and competitive intensity by combining with current environment. ②…

    • 19992 Words
    • 80 Pages
    Great Essays