Comparison Of Anne Frank And Hackett's Play '

Improved Essays
Melissa Müller’s text Anne Frank: The Biography, proves that Frances Goodrich and Albert Hackett’s play The Diary of Anne Frank is unjustified in using dramatic license because it makes the reader confused on the role of the resistance, he or she loses the actual account of the arrest, and it also removes the feelings of the gestapo.
Miep was not arrested in the annex, which questions the reader why. In the play Miep was in the country. Mr. Kraler, Miep and Mr. Frank survived and they went to meet up with each other to talk about how they got arrested. Miep says, “I got to the country to find food. When I got back, the block was surrounded by police…”(Goodrich & Hackett 433). Miep tells Kraler and Mr. Frank she was in the country, but the
…show more content…
The reader losses account of what happened before they got arrested. Silberbauer enters and starts to go through everything with the other officers. They reach a map which makes Silberbauer mad and sad at the same time. When Silberbauer, incredulous, shakes his head, Otto Frank points to the wall on his right: “Silberbauer’s eyes come to rest on a small map of Normandy tacked to the wall beside the pencil marks. On the map Otto has kept track of the allied advance. He has used pins with the red orange and blue head from Edith’s sewing basket to mark allied victories Silberbauer struggles with himself then he says in a choked voice take your time. Is he about to lose self-control? Has something here touched him?”(Müller 10). In Goodrich and Hackett’s play, they didn't talk about how are the SS officer went through Mr. Franks stuff and found the map. The map made the reader lose information on why it was taken and not hidden like Anne's diary. It also made him very emotional, because he found out Mr. Frank is a higher ranking than him and he should be listening to Otto, so he had to stick with be the main officer, which the reader lose all of that information on how Mr. Frank was the highest rank and how that affected Silberbauer. The reader is affected by why the reader lost information on the arrest scene. The reader loses more information before the actual arrest scene. In the play, everyone hears the SS officer banging and kicking the door for them to open up. The stage directions reveal to the reader that “The street door below is forced open. We hear heavy tread of footsteps coming up. Mr. Frank gets two school bags from the shelves and gives want to Anne and the other to Margot. He goes to get a bag for Mrs. Frank” (Goodrich and Hackett 433). Goodrich and Hackett left out the part of how the SS officer went threw the stuff, but they skipped to the part of them leaving. They

Related Documents

  • Improved Essays

    The true story of Anne frank Affected me in many ways. The story of Anne for me was a story of happiness, depression, fear and Love. The story was also very sad especially at the end of the When the whole family dies except for Mr.Frank. This story was also very sad because of the setting and because what was going on during that time period. When Hitler was trying to find and kill all of the Jews to make his perfect race, and all of the jews had to hide and fear for their own lives every single day.…

    • 583 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    She was Dutch woman of German-Jewish origin and was youngest child of Mr. and Mrs. Frank. In her work of the written diary, she is unambiguously precocious, charming and intelligent, and retained her cheerfulness and even during most testing and difficult of circumstances. Over the course of two years, she is transformed from spoiled and naive girl of thirteen into thoughtful and self-aware woman of fifteen. She did not have sufficient political acumen and knowledge, but becomes inquisitive to the length of asking the reasons and logic about anti-Semitism. While whole point of war does not make any sense to her at all.…

    • 1023 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sexist, or What Lord of the Flies Called for? There is something unusual about Lord of the Flies that is glaringly obvious. Why are there no girls? Was this simply due to the author’s choice?…

    • 535 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The play named The diary of Anne Frank tells the story of a teenage girl who is hiding from the nazis during World War ll. In this play, Anne struggles with growing up and finding her independence while in an attic with seven other people and a cat. In recent years, a movie version of Anne’s life has adapted the ideas and events from this play. In this movie, the audience sees Anne transition from her normal life in Amsterdam to her life in the Secret Annex. Although the play and the movie of Anne Frank’s life have different settings, both have the same characters and conflicts.…

    • 342 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The examination of what transpired is recounted in graphic detail in the book. Providing words from the characters at the scene, and within the town, permits the reader to visualize the crime and those involved. The passions of friends and strangers create a disparity of love and hatred. The images portrayed in the play are balanced, concise and offers an view to the…

    • 665 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    How do you think Anne Frank went through the Holocaust while remaining so confident in her situation? I think that Anne is just putting on a brave face so she didn't look childish. She was trying to make the best out of this situation. She realized just how poor things were around her. When the Jewish went to the concentration camp, the Nazis would make them work for food and drag dead bodies.…

    • 1047 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Sonny-Personal Narrative

    • 582 Words
    • 3 Pages

    It soon becomes clear to sonny he must go down stairs and find out what was in those bags. It is the morning its sonny’s chance to find out what was in the bags, Dario is outside of his door smoking making the hall way misty, it makes sonny wheeze because of his asthma. Sonny quickly runs down the 5 flights of stairs and runs outside to see the big black bags sitting on top of the big green removable bin. Sonny feels a gush of warm air like someone is breathing on him, He turns around to see Dario standing tall above him.…

    • 582 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In 1939, many people were faced with conflict due to a second World War. Nazis captured Jews, Americans rounded up Japanese, many people responded to this sudden conflict in a negative way, but some responded in a positive way. Having a positive attitude is the best response to conflict, especially in the time of war. A couple of books represent how two people named Anne Frank and Winston Churchill respond to conflict when it comes their way. One of these is Anne Frank:…

    • 919 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Anne Frank Injustice

    • 858 Words
    • 4 Pages

    It was estimated by the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum that approximately 6 million Jewish individuals died during the Holocaust. Those individuals led normal lives and had hopes and dreams, just like people today, but they were lost too soon. Anne Frank, one of those individuals, was a Jewish girl who lived in hiding in an office building with her family during the Holocaust. However, they lived in fear of being discovered. Throughout her living in hiding, Anne documented her life and thoughts in Kitty, a journal, and her stories told an insightful look into life during the Holocaust.…

    • 858 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Diary of Anne Frank Compare/Contrast Essay The Diary of Anne Frank is a story about a 13 year old girl who lived during the holocaust. Her and her family were Jewish and were forced into hiding. They along with 4 other people hid in the attic above Mr. Frank’s office, called the “annex”. The Franks, the Van Daans, and Mr. Dussel lived there for two years without stepping outside and relying on Miep and Mr. Kraler to bring them basic supplies, food, and information about the world. This story is mainly depressing and intense throughout the events.…

    • 443 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Anne Frank SFQs The pain Mr. Frank feels within himself when he returns to the attic rooms reveal a central theme in “The Diary of Anne Frank: A Play.” In paragraph 6 it states, “his eye is caught by something lying on the floor. It is a woman’s white glove. He holds it in his hand and suddenly all of his self-control is gone.…

    • 537 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    The Anne Frank play is a story about a teen girl growing up in a secret annex during the Holocaust. In this play Anne is struggling to find her true identity while trying to still get along with the seven other people she is living with in the attic. During the holocaust, Anne wasn’t the only one struggling to find herself, so was Elie Wiesel who lived in a concentration camp. Eli was a teenager at the time as well, who was jewish. Although Anne Frank and Elie Weisel have some differences in their character actions and settings, both value their fathers more than anyone else and struggle to survive during the holocaust.…

    • 457 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Anne Frank is a young girl who is secluded from the outside world within a hiding place her family and her take refuge in to escape the Nazis. Etty Hillesum is a young woman who lives alone and is also in danger of meeting an unfortunate fate at the hands of the Nazis, yet she does not live in isolation. Despite the fact that the two are both forced to endure the hardships of World War 2, their circumstances cause distinct differences between them, including their personalities and tones but also cause subtle similarities between the amount of thankfulness they share. Etty’s exposure to the world around her contributes greatly to her perception of the circumstance she is in and as a result affects her tone and personality. Because Etty…

    • 763 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    Anne Frank was born in Frankfurt Germany on June 12th, 1929. Being a Jew in Europe during this time was difficult and made her life troublesome. Hitler was searching for people of the Jewish religion everywhere. Due to this, at just thirteen years old, Anne had to go into hiding with her father, mother, and older sister. However, in 1945 when Anne was just fifteen, she and the seven other people living in the annex, were found by the Germans and were taken to various concentration camps.…

    • 703 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays
  • Improved Essays

    In The Diary of Anne Frank, the novel starts off by Anne Frank, herself, celebrating her thirteenth birthday and is given a diary of her own. She describes all of her friends from school that attend her birthday party in a hysterical way. Anne describes her sense of loneliness and feels as if she has no one to confide in. She decides to call this special diary “Kitty.” Anne writes about her family and teaches the reader that she has a mother, father and an older sister named Margot, and that the entire family all lived in Frankfurt, Germany until she turned about four years old.…

    • 623 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Improved Essays